10

All of the Pokémon in the animé say their names when they speak. For instance, Pikachu says "Pikachu" or some variation using those sounds ("Pika", "Chu-Pikachu", "Pi-pi-chu", etc). However, there are a few Pokémon, all from Generation 1 as far as I know, that don't say their names:

  • Staryu/Starmie (hiyah!)
  • Krabby/Kingler (kookie-kookie!)
  • Victreebel (*screaming*)
  • Electabuzz (whatever the heck this is)

Why is it that these Pokémon don't say their names while all the other Pokémon do?

  • 1
    Related question on Anime and Manga SE. – Torisuda Aug 9 '16 at 3:20
  • 2
    of note, pokemon can learn to say other things. case in point: meowth in the anime. – phantom42 Aug 9 '16 at 12:16
  • 1
    @phantom42 Somehow I doubt a Staryu could learn to hold a conversation, what with it lacking a mouth and all. – Thunderforge Aug 9 '16 at 13:50
  • Where do you think Staryu's bubbles, water, etc all come out of? – phantom42 Aug 9 '16 at 14:22
10
+50
  • Electabuzz

    I can’t find any solid evidence as to why Electabuzz has its bizarre cry. This site speculates that Electabuzz was some kind of thunder oni, though Raijin seems a more likely inspiration:

    enter image description here

    Pictures similar to this famous one, which depicts Raijin with two horn-like protrusions, might have inspired Electabuzz. Its horns also look like Raijin’s drumsticks. If Electabuzz was inspired by Raijin, perhaps its cry is supposed to sound like thunder?

    Maybe.

  • Starmie and Staryu

    These are easier. As noted here:

    Staryu has a very recognizable personality in the anime to those familiar with Japanese pop culture. More than any other Pokémon in the anime, Staryu and Starmie share the mannerisms of their cultural basis, the 1960s television hero Ultraman (the original Japanese name Hitodeman is the ultimate clue as hitode is Japanese for starfish). Staryu’s movement and “kiai” sound mimic Ultraman, but the most noticeable similarity between them is the jewel on their chests. When Staryu and Ultraman are low on energy, the jewel begins to blink and chime a warning alarm.

    Here’s the Staryu sound:

    And here is Ultraman’s sound:

  • Krabby/Kingler

    These Pokémon make an odd sort of chirping noise:

    Best guess, this is supposed to sound like a sound a real crab would make.

  • Victreebel

    Victreebel basically just screams:

    I cannot even attempt to understand why this is.

  • 1
    I appreciate this list! If you know any tidbits on other Pokémon with odd cries that I haven't mentioned, feel free to add them! – Thunderforge Sep 13 '16 at 1:44
1

Electabuzz is actually saying its name -- but in Japanese, where it's called "Eleboo" (エレブー) instead. Sometimes the localizations leave the original Japanese Pokemon vocalizations intact, which can result in oddities like this when the names have been changed. A similar example is Onix, which is called "Iwark" (イワーク) in Japanese, and can be heard bellowing precisely this.

  • 2
    Seams reasonable, do you have a source for this? – amflare Jul 31 '18 at 20:46

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.