9

In the Aligned Continuity, it was revealed that

when Megatron first began spreading his revolutionary ideas across Cybertron for a just and equal society, Soundwave was chief among his followers, being by his side from the very beginning since before the war for Cybertron even began.

Starscream, however, was an Air Commander who joined the Decepticons only after the war began. During the war, he has already demonstrated a traitorous tendency towards Megatron. According to some literature, he has even alternated between staying neutral or even apparently working in favour of the Autobots at some point.

Clearly, Megatron has had a much longer history with Soundwave than Starscream, and his relationship with Soundwave appears to be quite personal too compared to a purely soldier-to-commander relationship with Starscream - Megatron often speaks of his personal thoughts and plans before Soundwave when they are alone, a demonstration of their special relationship at a level Starscream never enjoyed to the same degree.

As officers of the Decepticons, Soundwave has proven to be immeasurably more loyal to Megatron and reliable on missions than Starscream - two of the top qualities that Megatron values most in a Decepticon, as their one true lord and master. In leadership and skill in strategy and tactics, Soundwave does not appear to be inferior to Starscream either. Even if that is not the case, he definitely makes up for it with the lack of cowardice and tendency to panic that Starscream so often exhibits.

However I look at it, from my interpretation of Megatron's perspective Soundwave just seems more eligible as second-in-command of the Decepticons than Starscream in practically every way I can think of. The only possible reason I could find for why Starscream is made second-in-command is the fact that

Starscream captured Sentinel Prime and delivered him to Megatron instead of escorting him to safety with the Autobots, as an offering when he sought to join the Decepticons.

This act by Starscream impressed Megatron, but surely Megatron would feel that all that has transpired since then would not be worth whatever benefit or advantage he gained from Starscream? So why exactly is Starscream kept around as second-in-command, and Soundwave was apparently never considered for the post?

  • 6
    keep your friends close and your enemies closer? Megatron, knows he is a threat? – Zoredache Aug 24 '16 at 18:33
  • 1
    I don't have any canonical answer, but that'd be my first guess. Second-in-command is often the first scapegoat. If Megatron really does like Soundwave, he might be giving him the benefits of influence, without the dangers/intrigue of command. – Matt Aug 24 '16 at 18:37
  • I feel like Soundwave has a sort of outside-the-chain-of-command position. – user31178 Aug 24 '16 at 18:43
  • @CreationEdge : Agreed. After all, Soundwave is superior. – Praxis Aug 24 '16 at 19:01
  • @matt that is also my view about soundwave. although I NEVER get why starscream lives.......normally megatron does away with everyone who is a failure or who tries to get into his back.....and Starscream does both time and time and again. – Thomas Aug 24 '16 at 19:17
7

Regardless of which continuity I have seen so far (aligned and also a few of its predecessors), Starscream joined the Decepticons while betraying his old allies.

Megatron himself is not dumb though. He knows 2 things. First that Soundwave will always stay loyal even if he is not promoted. Second that Starscream is power hungry and traitorous AND useful (to some extent). So what position is best than 2nd in command for him?

In this position Megatron can watch him, while Starscream feels important. Additionally Soundwave can watch Starscream without the later trying to assassinate him to obtain the 2nd in command position (which Starscream would else do sooner rather than later......he even tried time and again to assassinate Megatron himself to gain even more power). And Soundwave thus is in a position where he can warn Megatron or sabotage Starscreams attempts to undermine/do away with Megatron.

Also for Starscream the feeling important thing is quite important. He has such a strong ego that he needs that, in order to do his duty and ONLY betray his allies when pushed (else he would do so on a whim of a hurt ego even as seen a few times in different continuum episodes).

So all in all the 2nd in command is the best solution Megatron can come up with. As it brings him a capable warrior, someone he can punch and who comes back to still serve him while minimizing the risk of Starscream plans to gain command of the Decepticons. And as soon as Starscream is no longer more of an asset than a liability.....he will go the way of all things that displease Megatron.

What really is a wonder though is that Megatron thinks that Starscreams abilities/plus points outweigh his incompetence/failures. And thus that Starscream still lives (despite him always loosing). With Megatrons tendency to even kill loyal failures.....that is something of a mystery there though (and as far as I know not explained in any way in any continuum).

Additionally in many of the continuums Megatron somehow seems to be amused by Starscream AND his attempts to ursurp his position (although this is only an observation and interpretation, thus not part of the answertext above).

Edit: I found something as to why Starscream is not killed by Megatron and also what adds to his usefulness (and thus in the end why he ends up in the 2nd in command position). As stated in another question from here: Why didn't Megatron kill Starscream in G1? According to an answer there by Wikis Starscream is not as much a failure as I myself always perceived, but instead very good at his job.

  • I do agree though, credit where credit is due, Starscream is good at coming up with schemes, and that is useful when they are directed at Autobots. He is very good in the execution too, given how he takes pride in doing so with exceptional style and flair. His only flaw is in always messing up when things go wrong lol. Yet, he usually fails only when Optimus himself is involved or he himself was betrayed. – thegreatjedi Aug 26 '16 at 3:01
  • Or when he tried to betray Megatron. That always backfires at him. And he dies either doing something good or betraying Megatron^^ – Thomas Aug 26 '16 at 20:38
  • Conclusion: Starscream has plot armour against everyone lower ranking than him, and even against Megatron and Optimus its incredibly hard to penetrate. That must be why Megatron almost never killed him. Even Optimus doesn't enjoy so much plot armour across the continuities. – thegreatjedi Aug 27 '16 at 0:21
  • Optimus dies more often than Mary sue...aehm Starscream^^ – Thomas Aug 27 '16 at 13:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.