8

Having just watched Empire Strikes Back again with my sons, I noticed that Luke and his fellow speeder pilots are under heavy fire on every attack run.

The thing is: The AT-ATs appear to only have forward firing weapons with a small angle, and they are not fanning out to cover more angles. There are no anti-aircraft weapons shown anywhere in the scene. They are mostly untouched while circling the walkers or attacking from the side on one occasion.

This implies that after every run, the speeders regrouped directly in front of the walkers for the next suicidal run. Why did they do this and not attack repeatedly from the sides?

Note: I can imagine attacking from the rear was impossible due to the shield's proximity as well as useless due to armor, but the vulnerable neck is most exposed from the sides, and they were able to fly there in the movie.

5

In fact they did attack from the side as well as head on.

screenshot from The Empire Strikes Back showing the side of an AT-AT seen from the cockpit of a Snowspeeder

Both head on attacks (presumably aimed at the cockpit), side (the troop transport areas) and legs all proved ineffective as the armour was "too strong for blasters".

  • Good answer. Also, you can see at the beginning of the clip that the walkers are spread out in a long column, so even while flying past the walkers or attacking from the side, the speeders would still be under fire from the walkers to the rear. – Brandon Sep 1 '16 at 6:39
5

The rebel pilots had two key tasks here; to destroy the walkers (if possible) or simply distract the walkers (preventing them from firing upon the shield generators and the troops in the trenches). Flying around behind the walkers would clearly give a personal tactical advantage, but given their heavy armour there's actually very little point firing off ineffective pot-shots while the walker blows up the stuff in front of it.

Note also that the ultimate goal here isn't to destroy the walkers or kill the ground troops, it's to run 'interference' and give the rebel ships time to escape. That means getting in front of them and making themselves a visible nuisance.

Two blasts explode just off the speeder’s starboard side. You bank hard right, circumnavigating the explosion and flying out wide to the beast’s flank, where its great tusk-like guns can’t hit you. Then you kick up the accelerator and aim at its legs. “You with me, Dak?”

“I’m okay, sir.” He doesn’t sound okay.

From the trenches in front of the base, rebel fire keeps the platoons of stormtroopers at bay, preventing them from rushing the power generators. This is the point of the whole attack. No power generators, no shields. No shields, and those Star Destroyers up in the sky scorch the rebel base into oblivion.

Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back - So You Want to be a Jedi?

  • This is the answer right here. – Null Sep 1 '16 at 20:21
  • @Null - I'm still trying to find a gif of Duckman running through the shot shouting "I'm a distraction! I'm a distraction!!!" – Valorum Sep 1 '16 at 20:28
0

They didn't know the AT-AT's were well heavily armored. Not counting Rebels, this is the first time we've seen AT-AT's on the big screen. They, like us, didn't know that the walkers could take a beating and give some themselves. For all they knew, they thought firing at their heads would've finished them off.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.