18

In Captain America: Civil War, Ant-Man somehow becomes huge and is strong enough to break a plane's wing. Yet, according to this accepted answer, his strength doesn't change when he changes size, as it's only "more focused".

So given his larger size, he should be weaker, not stronger, shouldn't he?

16

If you want the following theories and explanations in video form, Matpat made a great video about it.

"Rule of cool" applies here. There is no logical consistency. The MCU Ant-Man movie (Ignoring all comic canon here, only Earth-199999 applies) stated that Pym particles work by increasing or decreasing the distances between atoms, so mass stays the same whilst density changes.

For this reason, Ant-Man's strength becomes more focussed when he's small. This is shown a few times when he hits people while small, placing the full weight of his body into a single punch that is itself concentrated into a much smaller area than usual, knocking people for six. It's also shown once in the movie that the increased density means whenever he collides with something at any kind of speed, the full force of his weight also hits that object and can damage it. When he falls from the bathtub, his body impacting the floor cracks one of the tiles. For some reason, this concept was never shown again, despite Ant-Man colliding with all sorts of objects. It's also noted that given his relative small size, Ant-Man punching things should do a lot more damage than it appears to, putting holes through people rather than simply knocking them unconscious.

Another thing is that when Ant-Man

goes sub-atomic and gets stranded, he should have caused a singularity from being so small and resulted in a small black hole that swallowed the Earth. There's also the fact that this scene contradicts the way that Pym particles were stated to work in the same movie, as if they only reduced the distances between atoms, then once you got to atomic size, there's no more distance to reduce, ergo that's the smallest you should be able to go.

Following the same science, objects that grow should lose density, meaning that when

The Ant and the Thomas The Tank Engine toy

get blown up to massive size, they should have simply floated away due to their much lower density making them less dense than air. Same thing should have happened when Lang became Giant-Man. But Marvel decided that the way Pym particles work is they turn him into a superhero, rather than following any consistent science.

  • 7
    "But Marvel decided that the way Pym particles work is they turn him into a superhero, rather than following any consistent science." Yup, I feared that. Thanks! – Olivier Grégoire Sep 30 '16 at 9:17
  • 1
    Well I think that being black hole doesn't swallow the earth. I think it would qualify as a micro black hole and "quantum mechanical arguments predict that micro black holes evaporate almost instantaneously." – Ivo Beckers Sep 30 '16 at 9:50
  • @OlivierGrégoire if you accept the answer, please kindly mark it as the accepted answer. :) Also I am amused that this ridiculous scientific explanation is still being used nearly a hundred years after Slan. – Broklynite Sep 30 '16 at 10:20
  • 1
    @Broklynite I will. I already +1'd. I usually leave an answer unchecked a few hours to allow more answers to be posted. – Olivier Grégoire Sep 30 '16 at 11:51
  • Matpat explains in his video why the black hole is an actual black hole and not a micro one that dissipates almost instantly. Essentially, the fact that Scott shrinks well past the necessary Schwarzchild radius while maintaining his ordinary human mass of about 90Kg means that the Black Hole would last long enough to start attracting more and more mass until eventually it swallows up the Earth and probably the rest of the solar system aswell before slowly dissipating over the course of a few Unvigintillion years or so. – DisturbedNeo Sep 30 '16 at 13:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.