6

Is the mentat mantra beginning "It is by will alone that I set my mind in motion" from Frank Herbert? Or is it merely a movie addition? If it is in the books, which book(s) and chapter?

  • en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mentat#Mantra - It doesn't appear in the books and was (apparently) an invention of Lynch's. – Valorum Oct 19 '16 at 0:03
  • 1
    @Valorum Do not answer in the comments. – Lexible Oct 19 '16 at 0:06
  • Alas, there's no confirmation on that link that says that it was specifically a creation of Lynch's. It certainly doesn't appear anywhere else in that particular form of words, but that doesn't mean it wasn't inspired by something Herbert wrote. – Valorum Oct 19 '16 at 0:20
11

It’s always hard to prove the non-existence of something, but:

  • I read the original Dune trilogy (and every other Dune book written by Herbert).
  • Before I did this, I knew the Mentat mantra and the claim that it was not in the books. Due to this and general confidence in my awareness, I claim that I would have noticed the Mentat mantra (or any variant of it) if it was in the books.
  • I did not notice the Mentat mantra.
  • that's right. there is no mantra in the original books. Lynch changed lots of things in the movie (like the ornithopters for example) – azatoth Oct 19 '16 at 15:56
  • One could also categorically search electronic versions of the texts (e.g. for "by will alone"), I suppose. That would pretty much be strong evidence for non-existence of the text in Herbert. – Lexible Oct 19 '16 at 17:36
  • @Lexible: That would help, but it would not cover the case that the text was adapted for the movie. Also, I do not have electronic versions of the texts. – Wrzlprmft Oct 19 '16 at 17:37
  • Yes, but I did not ask about "adapted from" in any loosey-goosey sense. :) But I think we are in agreement. :) – Lexible Oct 19 '16 at 17:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.