6

In Douglas Adams's book Mostly Harmless, all creatures from Earth are returned to Earth for its final destruction along all probability axes, and Elvis exists on another planet as a lounge singer. The text, as I remember it, implies that Elvis was, in fact from Earth.

Are we to understand that Elvis returned to Earth on his own in time for its destruction? Or was he an alien all along? Or had he escaped Earth long enough before its destruction by the Vogons that he was exempt from having to return? Or was this a plot hole or sequel hook?

9

As I've said before on occasion, the HHGTTG canon is … complicated.

In simplest terms, this is just not covered in the books, but the ending of the final fit of the radio series offers some hints as to what might have happened.

In the final episode of the series, the babel fish saves Dent et. al. from destruction at the hands of the Vogons, calling them through the Whole Sort of General Mish-mash to the Restaurant at the End of the Universe, where Fenchurch has been waiting for Arthur at the end of time, and Trillian and Tricia McMillan are merged, essentially undoing the final step in the plan to destroy the Earth and all traces of it.

This doesn't relate to Elvis per se, but it indicates that

the plan to eradicate the Earth and all its children simply failed, neatly resolving the problem of his continued presence at the Domain of the King.

If the books are kept as the only source, then the matter is simply unresolved, although

And Another Thing... introduces new complexities and twists, wherein the plan again simply fails, and his continued presence requires no further explanation.

  • Thanks. Perhaps I will listen to the radio series. – Michael Stern Nov 9 '16 at 12:31

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.