3

In the movie Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 2, at the Lestranges' vault.

Harry: Lumos.
Their wands cast balls of light.
Hermione: Accio Horcrux.
Griphook: No kind of magic would work in here.

If that is so, how the hell did Harry, Hermione, and Ron cast the spell Lumos, if no kind of magic would work?

14

Hmmm I think you must have misheard, the correct quote is

Griphook: That kind of magic won't work in here.

enter image description here

(The above is a screenshot taken from my copy of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 on DVD, with English subtitles turned on.)

So it's as per the books, you can certainly do magic in the Lestrange's vault, but you can't summon specific objects as an extremely straightforward way of circumventing the Gemino and Flagrante Curses, which are part of the protection.

  • this should be Best answer, the other one contains false information – Ghoti and Chips Nov 27 '16 at 23:03
  • Perhaps, yes. Thank you for the information! – Invoker Nov 28 '16 at 13:05
3

It is true that they used Lumos in the vault in the book, and it worked, but what Griphook says is not "No kind of magic would work in here."

This is the relevant scene:

“Accio Cup!” cried Hermione, who had evidently forgotten in her desperation what Griphook had told them during their planning sessions.

“No use, no use!” snarled the goblin.

He is not saying that magic doesn't work in the vault, he is saying that you cannot summon a Horcrux. This is further enforced many other times, including here:

She raised her wand and said, “Accio Locket!”

Nothing happened. Ron, who had been searching the folds of the faded curtains, looked disappointed.

“Is that it, then? It’s not here?”

“Oh, it could still be here, but under counter-enchantments,” said Hermione. “Charms to prevent it being summoned magically, you know.”

Many spells are used in Gringotts, including the Imperius Curse, Cushioning Charms, Confounds charms, etc. by the trio in that visit alone. When Griphook says "No kind of magic would work in here," I assume he means "no magic like that works on the Horcrux."


That all being said, the true reason for this problem is because the movies are nonsense.

  • oh. so the enchantment just works for the horcruxes. i must have read the 7th book, i only read the 1st to third. thanks! – Invoker Nov 27 '16 at 16:10
  • 2
    I don't think that Griphook knew the exact nature of the object they were searching for. So his warning could not have been specific to horcruxes. – TGnat Nov 27 '16 at 16:44
  • 2
    @TGnat As it says in the book, Griphook had told them before that they could not summon what was in the vault. It is probably common for objects in the vaults to be enchanted like that. – CHEESE Nov 27 '16 at 16:45
  • 1
    @GhotiandChips He is saying "You can't summon what is in the vault." Presumably people's belongings in vaults have this kind of enchantment on them a lot. – CHEESE Nov 27 '16 at 22:51
  • 3
    Oh, I understand what the goblin means, but your answer literally says, "he is saying that you cannot summon a Horcrux.", so your answer implies a false assumption, that Griphook not only knows about Horcruxes in general, but that he knows the trio are looking for one in Bella's vault, which is absolute rubbish information. I'm critiquing the answer, the other one is better, in my opinion. – Ghoti and Chips Nov 27 '16 at 22:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.