7

I'm trying to understand the timeline of the celebration of Rumarie among Vulcans in relation to the the rejection of emotion to follow logic and Surak's other teaching.

It's hard to imagine Surak, his followers, and later somberly logic Vulcans taking off their clothes, greasing themselves up with Rillan grease, and chasing each other around. These weren't exactly primitive times on Vulcan either - they already had nuclear weapons and interstellar travel.

However, on the Voyager episode Meld, Tuvoc told Neelix this holiday was celebrated as such until 1,000 years ago. My research on Wikipedia and Alpha Memory seems to indicate that Surak lived 1,800 - 2,000 years prior, thus Surak and Vulcans for 1,000 years after his teaching still observed the customs of Rumarie?

If so, perhaps an explaination of the logic is in order.

Alpha Memory:

Rumarie was an ancient pagan festival on the planet Vulcan that was last observed during the 14th century AD.

In 2372, while learning about Vulcan holidays, Neelix discovered Rumarie, which he described as a festival "full of barely clothed Vulcan men and women, covered in slippery Rillan grease, chasing one another." (VOY: "Meld")

10

According to Memory Alpha, Surak's teachings were not instantly accepted. The Time of Awakening took 1,500 years. If it started in the Earth 4th century AD, that means would not be complete until the 19th century.

Rumarie was an ancient pagan festival on the planet Vulcan that was last observed during the 14th century AD. So it's possible that it was still being celebrated by people who had not yet converted to Surak's philosophy. And maybe some converts even thought it would be logical to continue celebrating for some reason.

As for whether Surak personally participated in Rumarie celebrations, we don't know for sure (but I'm guessing he didn't). Just because it's a Vulcan holiday doesn't mean every single Vulcan participates. After all, Christmas has become a holiday celebrated all over Earth, but we celebrate in different ways and many people don't celebrate it at all.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.