9

After entering the Dyson sphere the Enterprise was forced directly towards the sun of the system and could barely escape flying directly into it with the crew coming to the conclusion that they could survive for maybe three hours and couldn't escape.

But when Scotty and Geordi opened the gate to the sphere again, the Enterprise could suddenly maneuver again and fly towards the gate with no problems. How did they get maneuverability back so suddenly?

At that point Scotty concluded that his ship holding the gate open would be in the Enterprise's way and would have to be destroyed for the Enterprise to get through. Why did nobody consider simply flying a bit below or above Scotty's ship?

Compare the Enterprise's size here to the picture posted below. It would have fit through the gate above or below Scotty's ship easily.

enter image description here

13

To expand on @Izkata's answer, the two source images are of different scale (and even the aspect ratios are slightly skewed!).

An overlay of the two pictures makes this obvious. First, though, I added some red and yellow dots in the same place on each image to make comparisons easier, and to aide in my rescaling:

Original #1 Original #2

Then I overlayed one on the other, with 70% transparency for comparison sake:

Overlay

Then I adjusted the scale to be the same (or as close as I could get it--clearly it's not perfect, due to some apparent change of aspect ratio and/or angle of the model during the shots):

Scale-adjusted overlay

And finally, now we can take the Enterprise from image #1 and superimpose it on Image #2 to see that indeed, the Enterprise would have fit through the door if flown at an angle. Although it's a much tighter fit than the image in the other answer would have you believe.

Enterprise super-imposed on adjusted image

Of course the real answer (out of universe) for why the Jenolan had to be destroyed, is that this is what the script said, and the special-effects team simply didn't portray the story accurately on-screen.

  • Yep, that's exactly what I tried to do, but I guess I didn't do it very well. (I didn't bother with the dots, I estimated the scaling by sight alone) – Izkata Apr 21 '12 at 19:34
  • @Izkata: It took me way more time than I care to admit to get it right. I'm too much of a geek/nerd/whatever for my own good. :P – Flimzy Apr 21 '12 at 19:36
  • 1
    According to your last picture the Enterprise would have easily fit through the door. Just rotate it a bit (counterclockwise halfway to horizontal). – Andrew J. Brehm Apr 21 '12 at 22:26
  • @AndrewJ.Brehm: Indeed, answer updated. – Flimzy Apr 22 '12 at 6:55
  • Now the last remaining mystery is why the Enterprise didn't fly away from the sun in the first place. – Andrew J. Brehm Apr 22 '12 at 12:46
6

The Enterprise could maneuver again because partial impulse power had been restored, as reported by Riker.

As for why the Jenolan had to be destroyed - just take a look at its size compared to the door. Not only wasn't there enough room for the Enterprise to maneuver around it, they didn't have much time before the Jenolan's shields failed completely, and they only had partial impulse power.

_Jenolan_ wedged in door

EDIT

Using the picture just added to the question, and the edge of the door scaled to be the same size, here's the Enterprise superimposed on the image above:

enter image description here

Yes, that appears to be a much easier fit than the Enterprise ended up having. However, keep in mind my other two points:

  • The impulse engines weren't at full strength. The best analogy I can think of is a boat, where you can only turn the wheel an inch or two: You might end up going in the direction you want, if you had enough time and space.
  • They didn't have much time before the Jenolan was destroyed anyway. If the door continued closing while the Enterprise was in that position, they definitely wouldn't have made it.
  • Looks to like the Enterprise could have passed below or above the Jenolan. And if partial impulse power was enough to steer the Enterprise away from the star, why didn't they do exactly that before the gate was open again? – Andrew J. Brehm Apr 21 '12 at 16:35
  • @AndrewJ.Brehm See edits. Thanks for finding that picture, too, I didn't see it on the article for Relics. – Izkata Apr 21 '12 at 17:35
  • I think it would still have been much easier to navigate than with the doors already nearly closed. The longer the Jenolan was still there, the opener the doors would have remained. – Andrew J. Brehm Apr 21 '12 at 17:46

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.