4

In the 50th anniversary special The Day of the Doctor (the only multi-Doctor story in New Who), the following short exchange explains that War and Ten will be unable to remember any of the events of the episode, and only Eleven, the most recent incarnation, will retain memory of them:

WAR DOCTOR: I won't remember this, will I?
11TH DOCTOR: The time streams are out of sync. You can't retain it, no.
[...]
10TH DOCTOR: I won't remember either [...]

As well as the necessity of ensuring that Nine and Ten truly believe they destroyed Gallifrey, even in the new version of time (otherwise their entire personalities would have been different), this also neatly takes care of the question of "why doesn't Eleven, the most recent incarnation, simply remember everything that happened in this episode and tell/warn the others?"

Was this same idea of "time streams out of sync" used in the multi-Doctor stories in Old Who? If not, how (if at all) was the issue of memory retention taken care of there? Back then, how did they deal with the issue of the most recent Doctor knowing exactly what was going to happen by virtue of already having the others' memories of the same events?

  • I vaguely remember some sort of name for the effect, but yes, it was effectively the same idea I believe. Not well versed in the old Who though, so I'll let someone more detailed answer. – Radhil Feb 17 '17 at 12:32
  • This brings up an inconsistency. There is a short where #5 (Peter Davidson) collides his TARDIS into #10's . This is just before the SS Titanic crashes into the TARDIS. David Tenant's Doctor claims he is able to resolve the situation because #5 saw him do it and he remembers how. Bit of an odd closed loop with no true origin, there. But, there is no talk of time streams being out of sync. – Verdan Feb 17 '17 at 12:45
  • In most cases where two Doctors met, this was carefully orchestrated by the TimeLords, by taking a Doctor out of his own time stream and putting him in the other's. And yes, it was always emphasized that whenever he would be put back in his own, he would have no memories of the shared events. – Mr Lister Feb 17 '17 at 12:55
  • Wibbly Wobbly, Timey Wimey? – DisturbedNeo Feb 17 '17 at 14:00
  • I explored some of the possible explanations in my answer to a similar question here: scifi.stackexchange.com/a/70785/22493 – Roger Feb 17 '17 at 14:10
5

The specifics varied from story to story and were usually glossed over entirely.

This is Lampshaded in the novel Cold Fusion which lists a variety of reasons (mostly technobabble and deliberate third party interference), from a variety of stories before admitting that sometimes memories are retained:

‘Well, if he’s your future self, why don’t you remember all this from first time round?’

‘Does everything have to have a reason?’ Forrester asked.

‘Perhaps it’s magic.’

‘No, no,’ the fifth Doctor said, ‘the rules of time travel are very precise, and Mr Cwej here has a good point. Now, on both occasions that we met Omega, that was straightforward Blinovitch Conservation.’

‘That was true all three times, yes, but it doesn’t apply here,’ the other Doctor noted from underneath the console.

‘Yes, yes, I know that. Now, Zodin erased our brains with mind rubbers.’

‘I remember it well.’

‘But that hasn’t happened this time. The crashed TARDIS might have had misphased Relativity Displacers.’

‘It might,’ the seventh Doctor conceded, ‘but it didn’t.

‘Tachyon Backflush?’ the fifth Doctor suggested.

Chris sniggered. ‘Sorry – it’s just that it sounds rude.’

Forrester shook her head disbelievingly. Her Doctor stood, brushing himself off and taking his umbrella back from his past self

The fifth Doctor straightened. ‘There is another possibility.’

‘Go on.’

‘You do remember. You’ve remembered all along.’

The Doctor smiled enigmatically and tapped the side of his nose.

At the pre-arranged signal, Forrester knocked out the fifth Doctor with a swift blow to the back of the head.

  • Great answer! I last read Cold Fusion 20 or so years ago! – EleventhDoctor Feb 22 '17 at 21:09
  • @EleventhDoctor — One of my favourites of the series, my copy is rather dogeared :) It's just had an audio adaptation by Big Finish that's worth checking out. – Quentin Feb 22 '17 at 21:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.