-7

Are Hogwarts students obligated to play Quidditch? If someone wasn't interested in sports or didn't want to do it, it was fine, wasn't it?

  • 2
    Hermione never played quidditch? – Edlothiad Mar 19 '17 at 14:49
  • 1
    There are 7 people on a Quidditch team. There are four teams. So only 28 students play Quidditch. There are more than 28 students at Hogwarts. – CHEESE Mar 19 '17 at 15:06
  • @CHEESE Yes, but there's more to it than that. Theoretically, everyone might be trained in how to play but only the best make it onto the house teams. – Rand al'Thor Mar 19 '17 at 15:13
  • @Randal'Thor Being trained and actually playing are very different. – CHEESE Mar 19 '17 at 15:28
  • @CHEESE Right, but what's the OP asking about here? Presumably they're not asking whether every student is officially on a team - as you say, that's simple maths. The more interesting question is whether people have to go to Quidditch lessons (like PE in some real schools) or it's just an optional pastime. – Rand al'Thor Mar 19 '17 at 15:31
4

Are they obligated to play in the actual Quidditch matches? No.

This much is clear. There are only four House teams, and only seven players per team, but even taking the worst JKR maths into account, there must be a lot more than twenty-eight students at Hogwarts at any one time.

Are they obligated to learn how to fly brooms? Yes.

Madam Hooch's broom-flying lessons seem to be mandatory at least for all first-year students. Of course broom-flying isn't necessarily related to Quidditch, but it's certainly a necessary skill, and these lessons might be used by the Quidditch teams for talent-spotting, as when Harry was recruited onto the Gryffindor team in HP and the Philosopher's Stone.

How much Quidditch-specific training is mandatory? We don't know, but probably not much.

Beyond the basic skill of learning how to fly a broom, we don't know how much mandatory Quidditch-related training students undergo at Hogwarts. Harry, of course, is inducted into the Gryffindor Quidditch team after his very first flying lesson, and since he's the main character of the series, we don't see how things are for normal students where Quidditch is concerned.

How do the school Quidditch teams find people to recruit? We get some insight into this in HP and the Half-Blood Prince when Harry runs "tryouts" for new team members. (Perhaps surprisingly, this also involves re-inducting people like Ron and Katie Bell who'd been on the team already, even though we never before heard about Harry himself doing tryouts in order to keep his position as Seeker.) There are a lot more candidates than team positions, so evidently there's no difficulty finding people to volunteer for the team.

And if most recruitment to the house teams (except in special cases like Harry's) is by students volunteering and being tested, there's no particular need for mandatory training. Those who are interested in playing will train themselves privately - as Ron did in HP and the Order of the Phoenix, sneaking around with his broom while Harry was doing detentions - and those who aren't don't have to do anything other than learn how to fly a broom.

0

No.

There are lots of students who don't play.

It's only the people who try out and succeed who play. For example, Hermione doesn't play Quidditch.


As pointed out by @Gallifreyan in the comments, first years do have a (seemingly) mandatory lesson in broom-flying. However, there is no requirement to continue playing.


And even for those who want to play can't always - there are tryouts. For instance, take Ron in The Order of the Phoenix:

"I - well - well, okay, I'll tell you, but don't laugh, all right?" Ron said defensively, turning redder with every second. "I-I thought I'd try out for Gryffindor Keeper now I've got a decent broom. There. Go ahead. Laugh."
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, chapter 13

And @Edlothiad provided the movie tryouts in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince:


Remember, there are only a few people on each Quidditch team: 1 Keeper, 1 Seeker, 2 Beaters, 3 Chasers = 7 people. 7x4 houses = 28 people in the whole school. So, it is impossible for everyone to be required to play.

  • You might want to add that the first year broom flying lessons seemed to be mandatory – Gallifreyan Mar 19 '17 at 14:52
  • My book being missing is really annoying... – Mithrandir Mar 19 '17 at 14:53
  • Add the video from the film then – Gallifreyan Mar 19 '17 at 14:54
  • HP:HBD quidditch tryouts – Edlothiad Mar 19 '17 at 14:56
  • You could also say that it was (ideally) hard to get into the team in the first place, with the auditions and all (or you could just buy brooms for the whole team, Malfoy-style) @Edlothiad ninja :D – Gallifreyan Mar 19 '17 at 14:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.