13

In most every Federation starship design that I can think of, the nacelles have glowing Bussard collectors (red, usually, but blue in the new timeline) with the exception of the TOS-era movie ships. The Miranda-class, Constitution-class, even Excelsior-class ships do not have visibly glowing nacelles.

Even the Phoenix had nacelles similar to the later red and blue look of TNG and beyond. I would also be interested in counter-examples of later ships without glowing nacelles. Let's stick with Federation ships, though, as there are plenty else that have wildly different designs (like, let's not even start with the lack of nacelles on the Bird of Prey). See the pictures for an evolution of the Enterprise's nacelles.

NCC-1701 with strobing red collectors.

The Enterprise-A.

And back to glowy with the Enterprise-C.

Is there a reason, in-universe, for this change, and the subsequent switch back?

  • Do pre-Federation Earth ships count? – ApproachingDarknessFish Mar 24 '17 at 16:50
  • Might help to provide pictures of the ships. – RichS Mar 24 '17 at 17:08
  • @ApproachingDarknessFish, how far back are we going, as even the NX class had the familiar red collectors. I guess I'm more interested in what appears to be an interruption (or divergence) from a standard design pattern. – quantumswing Mar 24 '17 at 17:22
  • @RichS, thanks and done! – quantumswing Mar 24 '17 at 17:22
  • 1
    Yeah, while I definitely want in-universe, I would be more than happy to hear any out-of-universe explanations, too. I figured that it was just different designers, but knowing Roddenberry's level of engagement, I do wonder now if he laid down some sort of guideline, or if there is one now. – quantumswing Mar 24 '17 at 21:26
8

The best I've been able to find is the out-of-universe thought process of the designer, Richard Taylor.

I tried to give it a very art deco feel; for example, I added the parallel lines along the edge of the saucer. I spent weeks drawing and redrawing the nacelles. The front end of them is almost a 1940 Ford grill. (Star Trek: Creating the Enterprise, 1st ed, pp. 103-104)

and

In regard to the nacelles, Taylor has added, "The Nacelles were the most difficult part of the design of the Enterprise. I spent more time on their design than any other part of the Enterprise. I felt they needed to be linear and streamlined. I wanted them to look more powerful and complex, like something Nikola Tesla might have designed. Being the engines of the ship they needed an anti-matter effect around them when in warp drive. I wanted them to look like they might be heat exchangers. Finally, I gave them a deco feel and made them much more rectilinear than the cylindrical designs of the television model." (Star Trek: Creating the Enterprise, 1st ed, pp. 103-104)

No real word on why they didn't glow, other than that he was trying to have a very different feel from the original model.

2

It's worth noting that the nacelles do glow, but only when entering warp. Much like how in TMP the deflector was a creamy orangey yellow when in sublight, I think the idea is that these systems get shut down or cut off when not needed to improve efficiency.

They later kept the deflector blue all the time in the other TMP-era movies, which influenced the look of TNG-era ships. i think part of it is that the glowing looks more interesting on TV, which was lower resolution than film. of course, the ramscoops did glow already in TOS.

Also, sometimes in TNG-era shows, ships like the excelsior don't glow when they're just sitting there, but sometimes, they do.

an excelsior vessel docked at ds9 the enterprise-d parked next to an excelsior vessel

I don't think we ever see a miranda-class ship's nacelles glow when not at warp though.

the saratoga flying toward the borg in ds9's pilot

  • You can edit in the images by clicking the little picture button at the top of the edit bar. – Edlothiad Dec 15 '17 at 7:20
  • ah, you're right! i'm used to being able to embed images in most of these types of editors but i couldn't find it quickly (and i'm actually meant to be doing something other than being on my computer right now :P) but i'll try to remember to fix that in a few hours ^^ – katie Dec 15 '17 at 7:24
  • Yeah, I think a lot of it just comes down to the designers and when they remembered to be consistent or not. By TMP, there wasn't really a settled design paradigm, so we see the addition of a glowing blue field grill but no bussard collectors. And as for deflectors, there seems to be no overarching consensus on how they are designed. – quantumswing Dec 15 '17 at 18:50
  • okay, i did it! it took me longer than i meant to to get round to it though. i really like the way to embed images here, just putting a little ! in front is really quick and easy. i like how easy it is to to alt-text for screen-readers as well. much nicer than most things i've used, like... on dreamwidth it took me literally half an hour to figure out how to do it right. – katie Dec 16 '17 at 16:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.