29

In Star Trek: The Original Series, does James Kirk have any named superior officers, officers who would deliver orders to him and who would expect them to be obeyed? I seem to remember the presence of admirals in the series, but my admittedly skimpy research has failed to unearth any names or character detail.

48

During TOS, James Kirk holds the rank of Captain and therefore anyone who holds a higher rank is his superior. In later installments the rank of Admiral (and its various sub-ranks, such as Vice Admiral) was established the main rank above Captain, but on TOS the rank of Commodore was more often portrayed as being immediately superior to Captain. During TOS and TAS We meet several Commodores, including:

Commodore Robert April, a previous commander of the Enterprise.

Commodore April, animated, wearing a green Commodore's dress uniform

Commodore Barstow

Commodore Barstow, wearing a gold Commodore's uniform

Commodore Matt Decker, killed by the Doomsday Machine.

Commodore Decker, wearing a gold Commodore's uniform

Commodore Jose Mendez

Commodore Mendez, wearing a green Commodore's dress uniform

Commodore George Stocker

Commodore Stocker, wearing a red Commodore's uniform

Commodore Stone, who once oversaw Kirk's court martial.

Commodore Stone, wearing a red Commodore's dress uniform

Commodore Robert Wesley

Commodore Wesley, wearing a gold Commodore's uniform

Commodore Enwright

Commodore Travers

We also do see a few Admirals:

Admiral Fitzgerald

Admiral Fitzgerald, wearing a gold Admiral's uniform

Vice Admiral Fitzpatrick, who ordered the Enterprise to K-7 during The Trouble with Tribbles.

Vice Admiral Fitzpatrick, wearing a gold Admiral's uniform

Admiral James Komack

Admiral Komack, wearing a gold Admiral's uniform

Following Kirk's promotion to Rear Admiral prior to Star Trek: TMP, significantly fewer officers outrank him. At least one certainly does, however:

Fleet Admiral Harry Morrow, Commander of Starfleet.

Fleet Admiral Morrow, wearing a maroon dress uniform

Furthermore, after Kirk was demoted back to captain following the Genesis arc, he is again outranked by Admirals, of which we see several in the later movies starring Kirk:

Fleet Admiral Cartwright

Admiral Cartwright, wearing a Wrath of Khan-style admiral's uniform

"Bill"

"Bill", wearing a Wrath of Khan-style admiral's uniform

"Bob"

"Bob", wearing a Wrath of Khan-style admiral's uniform

And of course, throughout all of this, the Federation President, who while not necessarily a member of Starfleet, is Commander In Chief of all Starfleet forces and thus Kirk's superior.

The Federation President from Star Trek VI, an unnamed Efrosian

There may be more, but I'd say that's a healthy start.

  • 11
    Whoa, Sisko's father had been an admiral? Shocking! – ruakh Mar 31 '17 at 4:42
  • Kirk & the Enterprise also receive a lot of orders that are just said to be from Starfleet, and various Federation officials also claim authority over Kirk from time to time in certain circumstances. – Dronz Mar 31 '17 at 5:52
  • Probably time travel hijinks. Like how Sisko is Bell @ruakh – k_g Mar 31 '17 at 5:53
  • 1
    Is it canonical that the Federation president holds Starfleet rank? – origimbo Mar 31 '17 at 18:39
  • 2
    And nary a woman to be seen. So much for an egalitarian society! – Peter M Apr 2 '17 at 13:51
1

There were several officers in the original series who could order Kirk around, and mostly they were Commodores. Commodore Wesley is the one that sticks most in my mind. He commanded the fleet that challenged the M-5 computer in wargames during the episode, "The Ultimate Computer." Just about everything Kirk did in that episode was against his better judgement, under the orders of Commodore Wesley. Another one that comes to mind is Commodore Decker, who seized control of Enterprise to hunt "The Doomsday Machine." Basically, any Commodore in the show had the authority to command or override Kirk, though under normal circumstances Kirk was generally considered in charge of his ship, regardless of the presence of higher-ranking officers.

  • Decker was only able to take command of the Enterprise because Kirk was trapped on the Constellation at the time and not in communication. In any other circumstance, Kirk would have been justified to tell him to shove off, regardless of Decker's higher rank. And in fact he did just that when communications were restored. – Keith Morrison Mar 12 '18 at 22:21
0

Kirk normally is under the command of higher ranking officers on starbases and/or at Starfleet Command headquarters on Earth, although that is not usually mentioned in episodes.

All quotes are from http://www.chakoteya.net/StarTrek/1

"Charlie X":

Captain's Log, star date 1535.8. UESPA headquarters notified of the mysterious loss of science probe vessel Antares.

In "Balance of Terror":

KIRK: Open a channel to our nearest command base. Quarter hour reports on our position and status.

RAND: We finally received an answer from Command base, sir. They say they'll support whatever decision you have to make.

The Enterprise visits Star Base 11 in "Menagerie", where it is commanded by Commodore Mendez, and in "Court Martial", where it is commanded by Commodore Stone. It is possible that the commanders of the starbase are also the commanders of the region of space the Enterprise is assigned to in those episodes.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_I._Mendez

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Stone_(Commodore)

In "The Menagerie Part 1" Commodore Mendez aboard the Enterprise gets a message from his superior officer:

UHURA [OC]: Commodore Mendez, urgent. Subspace monitors show Enterprise receiving transmissions from planet Talos Four in violation of Starfleet General Orders.

UHURA [OC]: Captain Kirk is here by relieved. You are ordered to assume command of the Enterprise. Disable vessel if necessary to prevent further contact. Message signed ComSol, Starfleet Command.

The natural assumption is that Comsol is Com Sol, the abbreviation for Commander Sol (Sector?). But once it was possible to make detailed screen captures, it was discovered that Robert L. Comsol decreed General Order 7.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Robert_L._Comsol2

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Robert_L._Comsol?file=General_Order_7.jpg3

In "Space Seed" Kirk and the Enterprise are apparently assigned to a different sector.

KHAN: I have a few questions first. What is your heading?

KIRK: Our heading is Starbase Twelve, a planet in the Gamma 400 star system. Our command base in this sector. Is that of any use to you?

The star Pollux may be in the same sector, since in "Who Mourns for Adonais?" kirk orders:

KIRK: Lieutenant, relay our position and circumstances to Starbase Twelve immediately.

In "The Alternative Factor" Kirk gets a message:

UHURA: Red Two message in one minute, Captain. Starfleet Command. Code Factor one, sir.

And Kirk talks to Commodore Barstow, who may be the commander of the sector the is assigned to at the moment.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Barstow_(Commodore)4

In "This Side of Paradise": Kirk tries to contact higher authority:

KIRK: Lieutenant, put me through to Admiral Komack at Starfleet.

In "Amok Time" Kirk's superior is also Komack:

KIRK [OC]: Lieutenant, get me Admiral Komack at Starfleet Command, Sector Nine. Pipe it down to McCoy's office.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/James_Komack5

in "The Immunity Syndrome" Kirk gets orders from someone on Starbase 6:

STARBASE [OC]: You will divert immediately to sector three nine J.

KIRK: Sir, the Enterprise just completed an exhausting mission. We're on our way in for R and R. There must be another starship in that sector.

STARBASE [OC]: Negative. This is a rescue priority. We've lost all contact with solar system Gamma Seven-A, which the Intrepid was investigating. And we've just lost contact with the Intrepid. Report progress.

KIRK: Order acknowledged. Kirk out. Mister Kyle, you heard the order. Set course for Gamma Seven-A, warp five.

In "The Trouble With Tribbles" Kirk talks with Admiral Fitzpatrick at Starfleet:

ADMIRAL [on monitor]: Captain, it is not necessary to remind you of the importance to the Federation of Sherman's Planet. The key to our winning of this planet is the grain quadrotriticale. The shipment of it must be protected. Effective immediately, you will render any aid and assistance which Undersecretary Baris may require. The safety of the grain and the project is your responsibility. Starfleet out.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Fitzpatrick_(Admiral)6

In "For The World is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky" Kirk has to make the "extraordinary event" of contacting Starfleet Command:

ADMIRAL [on viewscreen]: Perhaps haven't made myself clear. Let me restate it. You have been relieved of all responsibility for the asteroid ship Yonada. Starfleet Command will take care of the situation. (end of conversation)

The end credits name Admiral Westervliet.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Westervliet7

In "The Mark of Gideon" Spock requests permission to rescue Kirk from the planet Gideon:

ADMIRAL [on viewscreen]: I sympathize deeply, but Starfleet cannot override Federation directives in this matter.

The final draft script calls him Admiral Fitzpatrick but the cast list calls him Admiral Fitzgerald.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Fitzgerald_(Admiral)8

  • Although the quotes are moderately interesting, all this answer does is replicate the (much better) answer above. – Valorum Apr 9 '18 at 6:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.