At the end of Season 10,

Dean appears to kill Death

The question I have is:

How can Death be dead if the Reapers are still active? Do we have any evidence pointing to the possibility that Death is just yanking the brothers' collective chains?

  • I don't think there's any reason to suspect he's alive, but if watching him die on screen wasn't proof enough that's he's gone, I suppose it's anyone's guess. As for why the Reapers are still active - I don't recall anything suggesting they would cease to exist or be incapable of operating without Death himself around to manage them. – Steve-O Apr 11 '17 at 1:41
  • Just to add to OP's point, he had a conversation with Dean when they first met that implied he couldn't be killed – Izkata Apr 11 '17 at 1:43
  • He implied that he would outlive God, but that doesn't necessarily mean he couldn't be killed, only that he never expected to. – KutuluMike Apr 11 '17 at 1:48

We actually don't know. Everything we see through Season 12 so far strongly suggests that he is, but as it's Supernatural, anything can happen.

The major piece of evidence we have that Death is really done comes from the Reapers themselves. In one season 11 episode ("In Form and Void"), they run into the Reaper Billie. She explains that with Death gone, Sam and Dean will no longer get any chances for resurrection. She claims that Death used to find it "amusing" that the two kept coming back to life, but the Reapers are pissed at them for killing their boss, so the next time they die it's permanent.

It's also notable that, when he died, Death's scythe crumbled to dust.

On the other hand, the actor who played Death (Julian Richings) has supposedly claimed at a fan convention that Death was planned to return in Season 12. As far as I know, that did not happen, but the show was renewed for a Season 13, so who knows. I will also point out that, at one point, Reaper Billie mentions something about "old Death" and "new Death", so if Death does return it may be a different character; perhaps another being "ascends" to take Death's place. At this point, that's all speculative.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.