I've been re-reading some Sandman stories, and this time it was "Ramadan", exquisitely drawn by P. Craig Russell.

One thing towards the end confused me, and I hadn't even noticed it in my first reading - "the other egg of the Phoenix", as told by the boy walking on the streets of destroyed Baghdad:

His question unanswered, Hassan stumbles homeward, picking his way in a series of child's shortcuts across the bomb sites and the rubble of Baghdad. And, though his stomach hurts (for fasting is easy, this Ramadan; and food is hard to come by) his head is held high and his eyes are bright. For behind his eyes are towers and jewels and djinn, carpets and rings and wild afreets, kings and pronces and cities of brass. And he prays as he walks (cursing his one weak leg the while), prays to Allah (who made all things) that somewhere, in the darkness of dreams, abides the other Baghdad (that can never die), and the other egg of the phoenix.

Surely he's thinking about one of the two eggs of the Phoenix that were in Rashid's palace, one white and one black:

And there was also in that room the Other Egg of the Phoenix (For the Phoenix when its time comes to die lays two eggs, one black, one white: From the white egg hatches the Phoenix-bird itself, when its time is come. But what hatches from the black egg no one knows.)

But which one? And even past that, why think of the eggs of all things?

I can see the first egg being a symbol of renovation, which would be appropriate in the case of Baghdad, but why say "the other egg" then?

  • 3
    "Why say..." .. because it's the black egg that stuck in your head, isn't it? Same way it was stuck in his, in the story, which is why he says it that way? A mystery your brain is itching to crack, knowing there's some other story there you don't know, some unknown to the familiar myth?
    – Radhil
    May 31, 2017 at 22:59

1 Answer 1


When the text (and the boy) states "the other egg of the phoenix", it's referring to the black egg.

Note that when it is described, the panel shows the two eggs, but only says the "Other Egg" is in the room. In then goes on to explain the difference between the two eggs shown, to contrast this "Other Egg" from the standard myth of how the phoenix is reborn. It's still just the black one that's supposed to be there (or if the white one is actually there, it is unimportant by comparison).

So the boy is thinking of the black egg. It's a mystery, a wonder, one of many in the tale, and it's a hook that keeps the memory of the story of the city alive in his mind.

As for why the black egg is focused on... (speculation reigns for the rest of this post)

Yes, the white one, the true myth of the phoenix would represent a renewal for a Baghdad that surely needs it, at least as far as the modern Baghdad the boy inhabits depicted in the comic (I do not wish to make any judgment on how accurate or inaccurate the depiction is to reality). I did find this article that tries to dive into the reasoning behind the deviation from the regular myth and what it might represent. I am not sure its conclusions are correct - the article seems to assume that nothing hatches from the egg, representing stasis and stagnation rather than rebirth and renewal, and bases the interpretation on that. That's a distinct possibility and a good opposite to the white egg, but the story leaves it ambiguous, explicitly leaves it a mystery, in both text and image (although the panel gives it a sinister spin).

A simpler interpretation, but possibly more relevant one, is that the black egg is intended to be just what it is, the hook that keeps the story in the mind of the child. The Baghdad of Dreams is the city that was sold to Morpheus, and it will live on in dreams for all time, by the terms of the bargain. So long as the story lives on, so does the city, and the black egg, the "Other Egg of the Phoenix", is just one of many mysteries and wonders (like the globe of demons, the door of fire, the merchants ridiculously convoluted tales of mystical origins for their regular fare (true? in dreams who can say...) or any number of other things that stick in my head just from memory) that hook and keep the story alive.

The boy dreams of a wondrous place, and the wondrous place lives on in his dream. It need be no more a wonder than that.

  • You asked why, and I rambled. Ah well.
    – Radhil
    May 31, 2017 at 23:27
  • 1
    Yep. I left this question before going to sleep, knowing Radhil would answer - thanks for it :) I like the "hook" explanation, I think it fits the story, and maybe Sandman in general (and you can see a hook-like talon protruding from the black egg). Jun 1, 2017 at 9:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.