3

Beginning with Season 2 of "Stargate: Atlantis", Colonel Steven Caldwell begins aggressively campaigning to replace Major Sheppard as head of Atlantis' military forces. Elizabeth Weir refuses and that refusal results in Sheppard being promoted to Lieutenant Colonel. Afterwards, however, Caldwell still offers to take the job on several occasions.

The head job will always be a representative of the IOA, and therefore a civilian, so it's not like he'll someday be in command of Atlantis. And besides, he's already the captain of the Daedalus, which makes him one of the highest-ranked people within Stargate Command, possibly only a step or two under Generals Landry & O'Neill.

Why does Caldwell so badly want to take the job as second-in-command of Atlantis? Wouldn't that be a step down career-wise?

  • 1
    Maybe he has a really bad case of cabin fever? I would too if my job consisted of being a two-week long taxi service between galaxies. – Thunderforge Jul 6 '17 at 1:50
4

In Atlantis, Steven Caldwell would only have reported to Elizabeth Weir and would have been the highest ranking military officer. He would have been solely responsible for the military forces in the Pegasus galaxy. If ever called back to Earth, that kind of remote command experience would almost certainly have resulted in a promotion (to brigadier general, like O'Neill).

Meanwhile, he's captain of the Daedalus. That had him on Earth every two weeks or so. Therefore, he was continuously receiving updated orders. Further, most of the work of the Daedalus was boring. He flew from the Earth to Atlantis and back. There wasn't sufficient autonomy or action to lead to promotion. And since Earth had so few starships, it was unlikely that he was going to be put in command of a group.

If he was angling for promotion, he needed to be in one of two places. Either on Atlantis and in charge, or he needed to be back on Earth where there were higher command slots. He may also have been angling for an Earth spot. Of course we wouldn't see that from Atlantis.

His role was probably rather frustrating. When he was at Atlantis, he was the highest ranking officer there. He was a full-bird colonel while John Sheppard was a major and then a lieutenant colonel. If something went wrong in Atlantis while Caldwell was there, he would catch some of the blame. But he had very little ability to make things go right in Atlantis. Sheppard was in charge, and Weir was actively blocking Caldwell from making changes.

Another route to promotion would be for the Atlantis Expedition to grow. That didn't happen in the show, but it could have. Particularly if Caldwell was the one choosing whether or not to ask for reinforcements. He could have made the military presence large enough to require a brigadier general and acted in that slot. A high chance then of being promoted to fill the slot that he was holding. Note how Sheppard was promoted to lieutenant colonel for much the same reason.

  • 1
    +1 Only two changes I would make. First, Caldwell was still on track for promotion just fine as the Captain of one of the few Earth space vessels. He wasn't stuck in that position. There are plenty of new commanders to take his place after training. I will agree that he likely was bored with it; it was fun at first, but after time... Second, he clearly wanted the expedition to grow militarily and become more of a military operation. He wanted more structure and procedure, whereas Weir and Sheppard were much more lax. Caldwell saw this as an invitation for errors and reduced efficiency. – Odin1806 Jul 6 '17 at 17:52

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.