11

In Game of Thrones, it is common to offer people the option to 'take the black' as a punishment for serious offenses, that is, to join the Night's Watch rather than face execution or imprisonment. Furthermore, as Wardens of the North, the Starks feel a particular responsibility to keep the Night's Watch strong.

So how come Robb Stark chose to simply execute Lord Rickard Karstark as punishment for murdering the Lannister hostages? Did Robb not feel the same responsibility to the Night's Watch? Would this option have been considered and then rejected for some reason? Would his counsellors have advised him to consider this course of action?

  • I think Ned simply was a bad role model in that regard. It's not only Robb, all the Stark siblings have a tendency to use executions as a (supposed) display of their leadership qualities. Jon & Janos Slynt, Sansa/Arya & [spoiler] - heck, even foster son Theon & Ser Rodrik. – Annatar Sep 14 '17 at 14:03
  • 1
    They only use execution for treason though. I'm sure other crimes would be less harshly recieved – Edlothiad Sep 14 '17 at 14:16
20

A Song of Ice and Fire

Leniency does not come with disrespect, it requires remorse.

“Has Your Grace forgotten that we are at war with Casterly Rock? In war you kill your enemies. Didn’t your father teach you that, boy?”
“Boy?” The Greatjon dealt Rickard Karstark a buffet with a mailed fist that sent the other lord to his knees.
“Leave him!” Robb’s voice rang with command. Umber stepped back away from the captive.
Lord Karstark spit out a broken tooth. “Yes, Lord Umber, leave me to the king. He means to give me a scolding before he forgives me. That’s how he deals with treason, our King in the North.” He smiled a wet red smile. “or should I call you the King Who Lost the North, Your Grace?”
A Storm of Swords - Catelyn III

This evidently shows that Karstark has no respect for Robb, thinking of him as weak for losing the North and for going on this fools plight to "rescue" his sisters and avenge his father. Even the Greatjon is enraged by the disrespect and beats Lord Karstark.

“Pardon him, then,” urged Edmure Tully.
Robb stared at him in frank disbelief.
Under that gaze, Edmure’s face reddened. “Spare his life, I mean. I don’t like the taste of it any more than you, sire. He slew my men as well. Poor Delp had only just recovered from the wound Ser Jaime gave him. Karstark must be punished, certainly. Keep him in chains, say.”
“A hostage?” said Catelyn. It might be best...
“Yes, a hostage!” Her brother seized on her musing as agreement. “Tell the son that so long as he remains loyal, his father will not be harmed. Otherwise... we have no hope of the Freys now, not if I offered to marry all Lord Walder’s daughters and carry his litter besides. If we should lose the Karstarks as well, what hope is there?”
ibid.

Robb had evidently given this though, with both his mother and uncle pleading with him, Robb had some reason to be defiant, something led him to his decision for execution and not a pardoning.

Robb later states clear and true why he had to execute the Lord.

“I know what I said, Uncle. It does not change what I must do.” The swords in his crown stood stark and black against his brow. “In battle I might have slain Tion and Willem myself, but this was no battle. They were asleep in their beds, naked and unarmed, in a cell where I put them. Rickard Karstark killed more than a Frey and a Lannister. He killed my honor. I shall deal with him at dawn.”
ibid.

Robb's honour had been tainted for that Lord Karstark must be executed.
Not only that but Robb could not look weak in front of his men. Any common sellsword would've been executed for the act, he had to portray the same strength for those of greater lineage. Showing weakness would cause his army to lose faith in him. He had to remain strong and fair, he passed the sentence, and he had to swing the sword.

Game Of Thrones

In the TV Show, Rickard Karstark repeatedly insults Robb before his death. Not only did Rickard betray Robb's trust. He broke his honour. Killing two boys in their cell while they slep.

"It's treason to free your enemies! In war, you kill your enemies! Did your father not teach you that, boy!?"
Rickard to Robb Stark

Rickard clearly does not value Robb's decision. Again, leniency doesn't come with disrespect, it comes with contrition. Of which Rickard showed non.

"Leave me to the King. He wants to give me a scolding before he sets me free. That's how he deals with treason. Our King in the North. Or should I call him 'the King who lost the North'?"
Rickard to Brynden Tully

Again Rickard calls Robb a craven, saying he won't be able to kill him, mocking the King, his King. Not only that but he also gives up on Robb's cause. After the Iron Islanders had taken the North while they were in the Riverlands, claiming he "lost the North".

Rickard Karstark: "The blood of the First Men flows in my veins as much as yours, boy. I fought the Mad King for your father. I fought Joffrey for you. We are kin, Stark and Karstark."
Robb Stark: "That didn't stop you from betraying me, and it won't save you now."
Rickard Karstark: "I don't want it to save me. I want it to haunt you to the end of your days."

Again, Karstark expresses his disdain. He continues to mock Robb.

"Kill me and be cursed! You are no King of mine!"

Finally, Karstark gives up on the King entirely. He shows no respect even at his death.

Unfortunately I wasn't able to find the clip so I hope some quotes are enough, I will continue searching later.

  • I see Rickard himself refers to "treason", and you're not going to get leniency for treason without some serious remorse. Great answer. – shaneb Sep 14 '17 at 14:21
  • 1
    There is a more to it as well. It may just be impractical to have him take the black. How would he get Rickard there? He's lost the north, and it would cost him men to escort Rickard there. Best case scenario, it takes a few months for his escort group to go there and get back, and he's at a critical shortage of men. I guess he could let Rickard Karstark go alone, but he would just go back to his land. If Robb loses the war, he doesn't have to care about his 'punishment'. He might even go to the Lannisters and give them information. Execution is his only "good' option. – EvSunWoodard Sep 14 '17 at 18:21
  • That would be the clip: youtube.com/watch?v=SlowcpKuQsI – Patric Hartmann Sep 14 '17 at 20:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.