5

Firstly, some clarification, as the term 'Grey Jedi' can carry multiple meanings. By 'Grey Jedi' I do not mean a Jedi who frequently goes against the will of the Jedi Council (such as Qui-Gon Jinn), nor do I mean a Force-wielder or former Jedi who is still generally 'good-aligned' but not a part of the Order (such as Ahsoka Tano). By 'Grey Jedi', I mean a Force-wielder that uses the Light side and the Dark side both, seeing the merit in both, and achieving balance between the two.

Fans have long speculated that Luke is, even if he chooses not to call himself by the title, a 'true Grey', as he arguably uses the Light and Dark side both during his final confrontation with Vader and the Emperor. It seems likely that our questions on the nature of Luke's 'alignment' will be answered in the upcoming film, so let's set him aside for a moment.

Apart from (possibly) Luke, are there any canon Grey Jedi in the Star Wars setting?

Alternatively, if there are none, are there any Grey Jedi in the Legends-level of canon?

12

Canon

There are a couple of candidates who might fit your description:

  • The Father of Mortis, from the kinda weird Mortis arc of Star Wars: The Clone Wars. He's quite emphatic in his assertions that Light and Dark need each other in order to coexist:

    Father: Too much dark or light would be the undoing of life as you understand it.

    The Clone Wars Season 3 Episode 15: "Overlords"

    In theory his two children, Son and Daughter, should also qualify, but they each lean in one direction or the other (this is actually kind of the point of Mortis), and the Son ultimately gives into the Dark Side entirely.

  • The Bendu, from season 3 of Star Wars Rebels, describes himself as being "in the middle" of the Light and Dark sides:

    Bendu: Jedi and Sith wield the Ashla and Bogan, the light and the dark. I'm the one in the middle, the Bendu.

    Star Wars Rebels Season 3 Episode 1: "Steps Into Shadow"

    Despite his claims, we know little about him and his philosophies, so we don't know how close he actually comes to your "grey" definition.

That both of these characters are vaguely-cosmic entities is probably not a coincidence.

Honourable mention goes to Quinlan Vos, a Jedi Master who learns the ways of the Dark Side in the novel Dark Disciple. He tries to balance the Light and the Dark but, without wishing to spoil too much of the novel, fails spectacularly.

You might also consider Asajj Ventress in the same novel, who teaches Vos to use the Dark Side without being consumed by it; but it's not clear that she really uses the Light Side either, so it's debatable whether she meets your criteria.

That being said, as I've mentioned on the site before, this trope is one that the Lucasfilm Story Group generally dislike, so you're not likely to see too much of this in any canon storytelling.

Legends

The most prominent Legends examples are the Je'daii Order from the Dawn of the Jedi comic series. One of the earliest Force-wielding organisations, they absolutely meet your criteria, believing that the ideal state of the Force is balance between Light (which they called Ashla) and Dark (Bogan):

enter image description here

The Light defined the Dark, as the Dark did the Light. When balance was not maintained, Tython reacted to the imbalance with severe storms and quakes. And so the travellers defined themselves, ever seeking a balance. They became the Je'daii, a Dai Bendu term meaning "mystic center."

Dawn of the Jedi 001 "Force Storm Part One"

This eventually fell apart, as depicted later in the series, but there are a handful of individuals later who arguably take up their mantle.

But for your definition, Kreia, from the video game Knights of the Old Republic 2: The Sith Lords is probably the closest. By the time of the game, she's both a former Jedi Master and a former Sith Lord, but has given up both sides of the conflict; you can ask her about this at one point, and she pretty much word-for-word quotes your definition:

Exile: Kreia, what are you - are you a Jedi, a Sith?

Kreia: Does it matter? Of course it does, such titles allow you to break the galaxy into light and dark, categorize it. Perhaps I am neither, and I hold both as what they are, pieces of a whole.

Whether or not she actually wields Dark or Light side powers (or both) is up to the player, but she's the only one who can effectively wield both in equal measure1, and she philosophically rejects the Light Side/Dark Side dichotomy. There's an interesting moral choice at one point in the game where Kreia chews you out regardless of which you pick:

  • If you pick the Light side option (giving money to a beggar), she says:

    Kreia: By giving him something he has not earned, perhaps all you have helped him become is a target. Seeing another elevated often brings the eyes of others who suffer. And perhaps in the end, all you have wrought is more pain. And that is my lesson to you. Be careful of charity and kindness, lest you do more harm with open hands than with a clenched fist.

  • If you choose the Dark Side option (threaten to kill the beggar), she says:

    Kreia: Cruelty leads to suffering. And when one suffers, it is the way of life to spread suffering. The suffering within builds, until its sound is all one hears. And when a kindness is offered, it is punished. And a greater darkness is served.

That being said, even Kreia doesn't really meet all of your criteria; rather than seeing the merit in both sides of the Force, she sees them as equally flawed, and her goal is to "achieve balance between the two" in the most reductive way possible.


1 In the game, your alignment score affects how easily characters can use Light or Dark side powers; the more Light-sided characters get a bonus for Light-sided powers and a penalty to Dark-sided powers, and vice versa. Unless you play the game very carefully, Kreia is the only Force-sensitive character who maintains a completely neutral alignment2, meaning she suffers no penalties for using powers from either side

2 Jolee Bindo, a character in the first Knights of the Old Republic game, comes close here. But despite professing to "see more grey than dark or light", in the end he turns out to be a Light-sider (if you choose the Dark side, he proclaims himself to be a Jedi and attacks you), foreshadowed by the fact that his alignment is ever-so-slightly Light-sided

  • This answers my question beautifully, thank you! Sadly, if what you say about Lucasfilm is true (and holds true now that its owned by Disney), my great hopes for Luke's arc or story in the next film seem very unlikely. Ah, well. – CGriffin Oct 11 '17 at 23:21
  • @CGriffin Yeah, I wouldn't hold out hope for Luke turning out to be grey in anything other than his hair. Personally I really like Pablo Hidalgo's comment here; note that Hidalgo is an executive in the Lucasfilm Story Group, but this is his personal opinion – Jason Baker Oct 11 '17 at 23:29
  • Is that a Sith Pureblood in that final picture? I didn't think they had any interaction with the outside galaxy after the dark side users were exiled. – CBredlow Oct 16 '17 at 20:12
  • @CBredlow Yes, it is. Dawn of the Jedi takes place in like 25,000 BBY, long before the exiled Jedi landed on Korriban, and that panel is even earlier than the events of the story proper – Jason Baker Oct 16 '17 at 20:16
-3

I've seen many argue that Mace Windu was a grey as he practices form VII saber combat (Vaapad). According to wikia: "As time passed, knowledge of Form VII became restricted among the Jedi Order, whose members were worried that its precepts would lead practitioners toward the dark side."

Mace also had no qualms letting his emotions flow. He on many occasions exhibits anger, hubris, and jealousy. But in the end he decides to kill Sidious, so that may put him on the dark side of the spectrum.

  • OP was looking for evidence, not internet guessing – Valorum Oct 15 '17 at 7:45
  • 2
    I mean, the evidence is in his fighting style and his emotions. But thanks for your constructive criticism. – Rocktopus306 Oct 15 '17 at 7:49
  • Any answer that contains the words "many argue" automatically raises my hackles. Who are these "many" people? Why should I believe whatever they've said? – Valorum Oct 15 '17 at 7:53
  • 1
    This is a place where people offer up answers I thought. I believe I gave a possible answer. If you don't like my answer, hit the down vote. I could care less. Just adding to the conversation. – Rocktopus306 Oct 15 '17 at 7:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.