5

Episodes aired before Star Trek: Deep Space 9 S04E06 established that

  • there is a "sellers market" for symbionts - hosts are in competition

  • joining a host outside of the symbiosis commission rules is risky, but not as risky as claimed by them (see the story arc around Joran Dax)

  • joining is possible by non-SC, medically proficient persons (as happens with Verad)

  • plenty of hosts exist that want to join but are rejected by the SC (see the Verad arc, see the arc about the field training)

  • the Trill homeworld is not isolated in space, so the rules of their society can be evaded in a DS9-like universe

  • the reassociation rule is not universally accepted as a moral axiom (S04E06, Curzon already being ambigous about is is hinted at)

However, in S04E06, the idea is maintained that exile from Trill, due to breaking the reassociation taboo, would mean certain exclusion from all further joining.

It would be more logical to assume a "black market" among rejected hosts and renegade joined hosts would quickly have formed, and also that it would be in their interests to spite existing trill society by making the lies about rare symbiont-host compatibility public.

Why has such not happened?

11
  • It's an interesting question, but I suspect that the answer is something along the lines of, nobody licensed has written a story about it.
    – Politank-Z
    Commented Oct 25, 2017 at 22:52
  • I think there was a series of novels in the not too distant past (2000's+) that involved an upheaval on Trill over parasites, memory-beta.wikia.com/wiki/Bluegill - symbionts and joining and almost all the symbionts getting wiped out - memory-beta.wikia.com/wiki/Unity_(novel) , memory-beta.wikia.com/wiki/Trill:_Unjoined
    – NKCampbell
    Commented Oct 25, 2017 at 22:56
  • 1
    You're assuming that an exiled Trill would be angry enough to try to cause the downfall of their entire species.
    – Valorum
    Commented Oct 25, 2017 at 22:59
  • 5
    There's likely a very limited number of Symbionts available to this black market. You would need a symbiont who 1: has had at least one life (since the first timers come from the pools controlled by the Government) 2: is willing to use a black-market (risky) doctor and an un-vetted (or personally vetted) host. 3: is willing to abandon association with the vast majority (probably 99.9%) of their own race in the universe.
    – ench
    Commented Oct 25, 2017 at 23:04
  • 1
    @Valorum Plus even if they did try and out this information (which not all renegades would have), how many Trill would believe them? The renegade has already branded themselves as a traitor to the culture (at least as far as we see).
    – ench
    Commented Oct 25, 2017 at 23:07

2 Answers 2

2

Demand for exiled symbionts is self-limiting

A trill humanoid seeking an unsanctioned joining (with all the legal trouble that entails) necessarily has a high degree of self-serving ambition. To preserve his or her own strong self-interest, this person should avoid joining with a symbiont that has been exiled for overriding its host's priorities with those of a previous host.

1

We never see anything on screen to be able to say one way or another, but I hope that the reasoning laid out below will be good enough to show why there probably aren't enough Trill renegades breaking the reassociation taboo to set up any kind of alternate Trill society or black market.

  • Symbionts are rare. Only about 500 are available per year for joining, versus 5000 host candidates per year. ("Trill symbiont")
  • The purpose of hosting a Trill symbiont is for the symbiont to acquire new experiences over the course of several host lifetimes. Reassociation with previous romantic partners runs counter to that purpose. ("Reassociation")
  • Being a host is considered to be a tremendous honor in Trill society, and initiates must go through rigorous training and indoctrination. The Symbiosis Commission would undoubtedly dump any initiate who didn't show the appropriate respect for the purpose of being joined — assuming they even managed to become an initiate in the first place. ("Symbiosis Commission")
  • Space is big. Really big. Therefore, there's an absolutely minuscule chance of unintentionally bumping into lovers from former lives.
  • Even before the Trill became a spacefaring race, planets are pretty big places too. I would also conjecture that the Symbiosis Commission would not place joined Trill in places where Reassociation was likely to become a temptation.
  • Trill hosts consider the life of the symbiont to be tremendously important. Exile means the end of the life of the symbiont.
  • Trill symbionts are very long-lived compared to the life of the hosts, and presumably are interested in sticking around and experiencing lots of new things. It's possible an old symbiont with lots of life experiences wouldn't care about exile as much as a young one, but this also argues against any kind of alternate society, since the old symbiont wouldn't be around for much longer.

These last two bullet points can be seen as begging the question — after all, the question asks why Trill don't form an alternate society or black market to get around being exiled, with a side order of spreading truth to the masses, and I've responded that they wouldn't do that because they'd be afraid of exile and death. However, I think there are a few things that make these points more reasonable.

For one, the Symbiosis Commission keeps a pretty tight control on aspects of joined Trill society, and keeps secret that far more Trill are capable of being hosts than are allowed to be, even from the majority of joined Trill ("Equilibrium"). For another, the Symbiosis Commission is very respectable. Assuming that the Trill interested in reassociating and breaking from society discover more people are capable of being hosts than is normally thought, who are other Trill going to believe when it comes down to it: the respectable, knowledgeable Symbiosis Commission, or a couple of Trill who want to break a centuries-old taboo? The relative paucity of joined Trill to the population as a whole also means that a significant number of like-minded joined Trill would have to exist and band together to form an organization that would last.

Certainly, Reassociation is still something that could happen and has happened in the past. It is a danger, and Dax and Kahn nearly succumbed ("Rejoined"). However, since there are relatively few joined Trill, the joined Trill have been carefully selected and trained by the Symbiosis Commission, the probability of unintentionally running into former lovers is extremely low, it is highly discouraged from a societal standpoint so as not to happen intentionally, and from the general desire to stay alive, I conclude it is exceedingly unlikely for there to be enough joined Trill who are both willing and able to be exiles and form their own alternate society.

2
  • "Trill hosts consider the life of the symbiont to be tremendously important. Exile means the end of the life of the symbiont." I feel like the question is specifically challenging this point. An exiled symbiont could likely find a new host easily enough. Either, there's a random nearby Trill when it's host is dying (see Ezri Dax), or a rejected host candidates who are willing to join with an exiled symbiont thus creating the "black market" that the question asks about.
    – Ellesedil
    Commented Oct 26, 2017 at 20:53
  • @Ellesedil I've added a couple of paragraphs to address my question begging. Since my answer is pretty much all conjecture based on what we see on the show, it's probably about as good as I can do here.
    – Dranon
    Commented Oct 27, 2017 at 2:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.