3

After the defeat of Sauron, Elrond, Cirdan and Isildur went to Mount Doom. Elrond encouraged Isildur to destroy the ring. Isildur, however rejected Elrond's bidding.

Now did Gandalf know that Elrond didn't stop Isildur?

If so, why didn't he (Gandalf) blame Elrond.

  • Don't know for sure, but maybe Elrond held back so he wouldn't be corrupted by the ring. If he'd tried to stop Isildur they would have fought, possibly leading to Elrond taking the ring for himself. He walked away from that temptation. Maybe Gandalf respects him for that. – Tim Nov 15 '17 at 19:55
  • 1
    I don't think Gandalf would expect Elrond to force Isildur to destroy the ring. Gandalf himself was wary of forcing anyone with the ring as he told Frodo: "I could not 'make' you [destroy the ring]--except by force, which would break your mind". – Quasi_Stomach Nov 15 '17 at 19:58
  • Tim, Because if Elrond stops Isildur it's going to be a risk that Elrond doesn't want – The Witch King of Angmar Nov 15 '17 at 20:01
  • 1
    I think an answer ought to take into account that Elrond was the Herald of Gil-galad. He was not a king. Isildur was, with his brother and father one of the three mightiest kings of men in Middle Earth. Regardless of his knowledge, one may council such a King but cannot demand anything of them. I feel like this is addressed in the book or an appendix but could not cite it. – Yorik Nov 15 '17 at 20:58
  • 1
    @Yorik After Gil-galad’s death, Elrond can be argued to have the right to hold the High Kingship of the Noldorin, although he denied it. A Kingship far greater than the Kingship of the men of Númenor, and the line of his brother, Elros. – Edlothiad Nov 15 '17 at 22:50
7

Firstly, there was no reason to blame Elrond or Cirdan.

As is extensively covered in this answer, Elrond and Cirdan had a reason not to take the Ring by force as it would have ensnared them, like it had Isildur, Gollum and Boromir. It is unlikely they would've had enough power to shake of the will of the One Ring.

So regardless of the answer below even if Gandalf had known, he would've known he could not blame Elrond for Elrond had done all he could do without corrupting himself and risking more damage.

This is also a good analysis (although without any quotes) of the nature of the One Ring at the time.

It is uncertain whether he knew, but it is possible.

The fall of Sauron led to the ending of the Second Age and the Start of the Third Age. In the year T.A. 2 Isildur and his three sons are slain. 998 years later in T.A. 1000 the Istari come into Middle-earth.

2 Isildur plants a seedling of the White Tree in Minas Anor. He delivers the South-kingdom to Meneldil. Disaster of the Gladden Fields; Isildur and his three elder sons are slain.
Return of the King - Appendix B: Tale of Years

They first appeared in Middle-earth about the year 1000 of the Third Age
Unfinished Tales: The Istari

In these 1000 years the One Ring had been lost, no one had ever seen it again. It was not for another ~1200 years that the One Ring had been found by Deagol and stolen by Smeagol. In this time it is not 100% clear whether Elrond had discussed the ending of the War of the Last Alliance with Gandalf or not. But as stated above, this doesn't matter, as there was no reason to blame Elrond.

Movies

From the perspective of the Movies, we can assume Gandalf had not known. Elrond says the following to Gandalf suggesting that he hadn't told him before, speaking as if Gandalf hadn't known before.

GANDALF: It is in Men that we must place our hope.

ELROND: Men? Men are weak. The race of Men is failing. The blood of Numenor is all but spent, its pride and dignity forgotten. It is because of men the Ring survives.

FLASH INSERT: With the broken sword, Isildur slices off Sauron's finger. Elrond reacts.

ELROND (V.O.) (CONT'D): I was there, Gandalf...I was there three thousand years ago when Isildur took the ring.

FLASH INSERT: ISILDUR PICKS UP THE RING AND STARES AT IT, ENTRANCED.

ELROND: I was there the day the strength of Men failed.

ELROND: Isildur...hurry...follow me!

IMAGES: ELROND leads Isildur into the steaming volcano.

ELROND (V.O.) (CONT'D): I let Isildur into the heart of Mount Doom, where the ring was forged: the one place it could be destroyed.

FLASH INSERT: ELROND AND ISILDUR STAND BEFORE THE FIRES OF MT. DOOM.

ELROND: Cast it into the fire...destroy it!

CLOSE ON: ISILDUR...CAPTIVATED BY THE RING.

ISILDUR: No.

The clip can be seen below

  • Well but Elrond didn't have take the ring from Isildur. He could have just killed Isildur (or tried to, anyway), and then sorta shimmied him off into the fire with his foot. Along with the ring. – Misha R Nov 15 '17 at 21:50
  • 3
    @MishaRosnach Kill Isildur would've been a perfect cause for corruption. Killing your friend never ends well in Tolkien's Legendarium, See Túrin. – Edlothiad Nov 15 '17 at 22:16
  • Also see Sméagol. Killing your friend to get the ring is even worse than just killing your friend. – Todd Wilcox Nov 16 '17 at 0:33
  • @ToddWilcox Well, again, my point is that he wouldn't actually take the ring. – Misha R Nov 16 '17 at 1:06
  • @Edlothiad As a related point, killing your friends never ends well in real life, either. – kingledion Nov 16 '17 at 1:07
2

Presumably. The Istari (of which Gandalf or "Olorin" was one) were sent AFTER Sauron's initial defeat. The Istari (Wizards) were sent to Middle Earth because the Valar knew that Sauron had not been defeated utterly.

Given Gandalf's relationship with both Galadriel AND Elrond, it can be assumed that he knew their stories intimately. He would have known Elrond was there when Isildur failed to destroy the ring. He obviously knew (or at least found out) the ring was missing, but that it had not been destroyed. Even Saruman admitted the ring had been "[Lost to the sea]".

So, in my estimation the answer is yes, he knew. But Elrond wasn't the bad guy in this situation and the Istari were not sent for revenge, they were sent to be actors on behalf of their associated Valar. They were simply sent to help. And, aside from Saruman (arguably) they did just that.

  • 1
    Gandalf does mention that his knowledge (and that of the Wise) went as far as the loss of the ring by Isildur in the Gladden. That implies that they all spoke of it, and knew what happened to it. I can't find evidence that Gandalf specifically knew that Elrond was there, but since Elrond mentioned his counsel (of Isildur) to the council (of Elrond), it is indeed hard to believe that Gandalf didn't know all along. – Quasi_Stomach Nov 15 '17 at 20:21

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.