78

I recently stumbled upon this video which is a 15 minute compilation of Star Trek: The Next Generation scenes where Worf makes proposals which immediately get dismissed:

That made me wonder if this is actually an accurate representation of how the Enterprise-D crew treated Worf. Are there any examples of episodes in ST:TNG where Worf proposed a course of action and the other characters agreed to it without further discussion?

  • 2
    And before someone votes: no, this is not a duplicate of this question. While it uses the same video, it does not ask about how Worf is treated. It asks about whether or not Picard ever fired first in a conflict. – Philipp Nov 22 '17 at 18:47
  • 3
    What about when Worf proposed to Deanna? – Edlothiad Nov 22 '17 at 18:49
  • 4
    @Edlothiad I was going to say the same of his proposal to Jadzia Dax... – Vanguard3000 Nov 22 '17 at 19:04
  • 8
    Now I want to know how many times he was denied, but it turns out the thing he said to do was correct. – n_b Nov 22 '17 at 22:29
  • 3
    Worf has made many reliable suggestions during the Enterprise's confrontations with Klingon vessels and other attacking vessels. – B.fox Nov 23 '17 at 20:57
109

There are a number of occasions where Worf's suggestions were immediately actioned by the crew of the Enterprise.

In TNG: Time's Arrow he proposed that they fire torpedoes on Captain Picard's location. With only a slight hesitation (presumably because killing his captain isn't going to look good on his resumé), Riker agrees.

WORF: The Captain would not. I recommend we target photon torpedoes on the alien habitat and destroy it. Immediately.

TROI: He's right, Will.

RIKER: Power up the photons, Mister Worf. Alert me when they're ready.

In TNG: Skin of Evil Worf tells the captain that he thinks he should stay on the ship. Picard readily accepts.

WORF: I will remain on the ship. The object here is not to engage the creature in battle. The goal is the safe return of Counsellor Troi and Lieutenant Prieto. I can best accomplish this at the Tactical Station.

PICARD: Very good. Number One?

In TNG: The Outrageous Okona he suggests that the roguish Okana should only be given access to the public areas of the ship.

WORF: Sir, recommend limited access to our ship.

PICARD: Agreed.

In TNG: Cost of Living Worf suggests that they evacuate some areas of the ship. Picard readily agreed.

WORF: We must evacuate decks twenty through twenty four, Captain.

PICARD: Make it so. Shut down life support to those decks.

In TNG: Clues Worf points out that they're within the blast radius of their own torpedoes.

WORF: I do not recommend weapons at this range, Captain.

PICARD: Can we go to warp?

In TNG: The Next Phase Worf is adamant that they can't give the Romulans a computer core. Riker comes up with an alternate solution to appease him.

WORF: Commander, the (looks round) the Romulans want a computer. We cannot give them access to Federation technology. That is an unacceptable security risk.

RIKER: What about a computer core from thirty or forty years ago? One the Romulans are already familiar with.

WORF: That would be satisfactory.

In TNG: Galaxy's Child Picard is practically his best buddy, accepting not one but two(!) proposals from Worf, that they move back and that they fire phasers.

WORF: Sir, the shuttlecraft shields did not provide sufficient protection for its computer. Our computer may also be vulnerable. I recommend withdrawal to a safe distance.

PICARD: Ensign Anaya, full about. Half impulse.

...

WORF: Sir, recommend full phasers.

PICARD: Proceed.

In TNG: Lower Decks, Worf proposes that they could use a probe to augment their sensors. Riker points out the obvious legal implications (as he's supposed to) but Picard is happy to agree with Worf.

WORF: Sir, I recommend we launch a probe to increase the range of our sensor sweeps.

RIKER: Launching a probe into Cardassian space would be a treaty violation.

PICARD: Mister Worf, prepare a probe and launch when ready.

In TNG: Chain of Command, Worf offers his advice on how to get through an obstruction.

WORF: A phaser set to level sixteen should suffice.

PICARD: Make it so.

Worf is on fire in TNG: Eye of the Beholder with two suggestions accepted by Troi; that they rummage a dead crewman's computer files and that they start early the next day.

WORF: We should check his personal logs.

TROI: This is his last entry. He made it before going on duty this morning.

...

WORF: We should get an early start tomorrow.

TROI: I think we should. I'll see you in the morning.

And in the TNG film Star Trek: Insurrection Worf is very clear in his proposal that they have to prioritise fixing their dampening fields in order to prevent the crew from being flung around.

WORF: We must stabilise the dampening fields.

PICARD: Reroute emergency power to inertial dampers.

  • 22
    Your google-fu out ranks my google-fu – Edlothiad Nov 22 '17 at 19:08
  • 10
    @CBredlow - It's definitely not worth the effort. Sisko and Kira were more than happy to accept his proposals, of which there were several dozen – Valorum Nov 22 '17 at 19:38
  • 9
    Skin of Evil is an early TNG example, when Worf suggests that he can serve the rescue mission better at his tactical station than by joining the away team as initially ordered. – Gaultheria Nov 22 '17 at 19:52
  • 5
    Technically, Worf suggested self destructing the ship and evacuating in First Contact: youtu.be/Q1VKPUey94M. Picard took convincing, but it was the course of action they took (with Picarding tacking on his staying behind). – jpmc26 Nov 23 '17 at 2:06
  • 6
    Another addition to an excellent list: The Emissary: However, Worf comes up with another option. [..] Worf and K'Ehleyr, clad in full traditional Klingon command uniforms, appear as captain and first officer of the Enterprise, informing Captain K'Temoc of the T'Ong that the war is over and ordering them to surrender. We see Worf start making a suggestion, his explanation (and Picard's agreement) happen off-screen, but afterwards we see Worf executing his plan. – Flater Nov 23 '17 at 9:27
9

Yes, his recommendation was accepted in the episode, The Emissary.

A Klingon emissary (and Worf's mate), K'Ehleyr, informs the command staff that Starfleet has detected a Klingon battlecruiser called the T'Ong, which was launched from the Klingon homeworld over 75 years ago, when the Klingons and the Federation were still at war. The crew has been in suspended animation and are about to awaken, at which point it is feared they will immediately attack the nearest Federation outpost, several of which are nearby and would not be able to adequately defend themselves.

K'Ehleyr urges Picard to let the Klingons die with honor, in battle. However, Worf comes up with another option. While Picard and first officer Commander Riker position themselves out of sight, Worf and K'Ehleyr, clad in full traditional Klingon command uniforms, appear as captain and first officer of the Enterprise, informing Captain K'Temoc of the T'Ong that the war is over and ordering them to surrender. K'Temoc initially refuses, believing it to be a Federation trick, but when Worf, in typical Klingon manner, shows his resolve and threatens to destroy the T'Ong, K'Temoc grudgingly agrees.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.