2

Watched the latest episode of The Gifted ("threat of eXtinction") yesterday on holiday. It shows Andrea and Andreas von Strucker in a flashback. Later, the character Reed Strucker goes to visit his estranged father, Otto. Otto talks about the older von Struckers as powerful, destructive mutants know collectively as Fenris. He mentions his parents at the time and that is tied to the von Struckers and I later assumed that they were in an incestual relationship, which surprised me for US network TV.

Looking into it today, the summary on Wikipedia says that Otto is simply the son of Andreas. However, the entry for Fenris specifically mentions their incestual relationship in the comics.

Did anyone else catch this in the episode?
Is Otto the son of both Andrea and Andreas?

4

The evidence is currently ambiguous.

In the scene where the connection is revealed, Otto specifically says,

"This is my father, Andreas von Strucker. My father and his sister Andrea did unspeakable things. They were terrorists. They were also mutants."

This implies that only Andreas is his parent, and Andrea is not.
Now, you could imagine, "He was embarrassed about it and so he was hiding the fact that Andrea was his mother as well." Or maybe "He didn't know his mother was also his aunt."

However, generally speaking, it's easier to be certain of a person's mother rather than their father. If he was born to Andrea von Strucker, he would likely have a birth certificate somewhere and hospital records, and so it would be more logical thing to claim "This was my mother, Andrea von Strucker. My mother and her brother Andreas did unspeakable things."

It is certainly possible that Andrea was his mother and managed to hide her pregnancy and Andreas, for whatever reason, claimed the child as his own, but it requires a lot of supposition that so far isn't supported by any evidence. The very fact that the Strucker kids inherited their abilities from their father (who had children with an unrelated human woman), who inherited it from his father (who presumably didn't have a child with anyone related to him), who inherited it from Andreas, suggests that only one parent is needed to pass on the powers.

It may also be that the elder Strucker siblings had an incestuous relationship but had other partners or relationships as a cover, or for variety, or for periods when they believed it was wrong. But for the first season there was no real evidence that Andrea was Otto's biological mother, other than that a few comics have hinted at that the twins had an abnormally close relationship in comics canon.

In episode 9 of season two, during a confrontation with someone who worked with Reed Strucker's father, she said,

"Reed's grandparents were monsters. They killed thousands of people."

Which suggests that his two grandparents were the Struckers.

However, there are other explanations: 1) It was a slip of the tongue in a tense moment, she meant "Reed's grandfather and his sister." 2) She was referring to Reed's grandfather and presently unnamed grandmother, who, although not Andrea Strucker, was also a monster implicated in the murders of thousands of people. One could easily imagine that, if incest were ruled out, anyone Andreas had a child with might well be at least comfortable with his acts and might also be a mutant. 3) She suspected incest but was simply wrong (given the character is a geneticist and had access to samples of Reed's genetic code, this is least likely but included for completeness).

It is enough evidence that, at present, I can't say "Probably not," (especially considering the comics constant hints in that direction between the Fenris twins) but not quite enough to say it is confirmed. Future episodes may shed more light on the topic.

  • 1
    I'll freely admit that the TV didn't have my undivided attention. I missed the part you quoted but did catch a later "They tried to raise me to be like them, but I ran away," which added to my confusion. Thanks for the quote. – eshier Nov 24 '17 at 19:03
-1

But he has the combination of their powers so my bet is yes and in episode ten Cample says that Andy and Lauren are DIRECT relatives of Andreas von Strucker and his sister. Aunts are second degree relatives so it's most likely Otto is a child of incest and their x-gene stops defects.

EDIT: in s2 ep9 Madeline refers to Andreas and andreas as reeds grandparents in the quote “reed’s grandparents were monsters”. So Otto Van Strucker is 100 percent the result of incest

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.