-5

I started reading the Inheritance cycle by Christopher Paolini before I started reading J.R.R Tolkien's Lord of the Rings, and I have to say, they seem pretty similar in the books. Of how Eragon uses the Ancient language for magic, and in LOTR someone tells of mysterious people outside of the Spire, using the language of beasts and land, which describes the Ancient language. I don't know, please help.

  • 12
    This is called "influence." Tolkien is one of the most influential authors in modern history. – ApproachingDarknessFish Nov 29 '17 at 19:07
  • 9
    The Inheritance Cycle is just super derivative, to be honest. The author was only a teenager when he wrote it. I don't think he had enough experience reading and writing to realize quite how derivative it is. inheritance.wikia.com/wiki/Criticism_of_the_Inheritance_Cycle – Kai Nov 29 '17 at 19:15
  • 3
    @Kai - it IS derivative, and even Paolini has admitted that. I still find the series to be an enjoyable read, though. Derivative doesn't always equal bad... I mean, look at Star Wars. – Omegacron Nov 29 '17 at 23:38
  • When I was a child I made a map that showed the area in the map of Wilderland from the Hobbit combined in one map with the map from the Phantom Tollboth. And I have seen some maps online that combine various fantasy worlds in one map like this one: mapsandthecity.com/tag/middle-earth that combines about 23 different fantasy settings. So any fan can make a map showing Alegaesia and Middle-earth in the same world as a fan project. But such a map will never be canonical in either The Inheritance Cycle or Tolkien Legendarium fictional universe. – M. A. Golding Dec 4 '17 at 20:51
8

While Paolini was undeniably influenced by Tolkien, there are several fundamental differences in the mechanics and structure of two worlds that show they're separate. You could write a whole paper on this, but I will list a few.

Magic

Perhaps the clearest, most fundamental difference in the worlds is the use of Magic. In Tolkien's legendarium, magic is mostly limited to things like influencing (controlling or inspiring) others, healing or corrupting people, prophecy and visions, crafting and shaping powerful artifacts (like rings and swords), and enhancing power or strength. We occasionally see a few more overt uses, such as when Gandalf uses beams of light to drive away Nazgul, or to disarm Gimli. It's very rare and exceptional to see anything more than that, and usually limited to the Ainur (essentially gods). See here for more information.

On the other hand, in Paolini's world there are comparatively more magic-users, and they can do bright, flashy, impressive things like throw fireballs, freeze water, deflect arrows, kill directly with magic, etc. Magic can be used as a direct, powerful offensive weapon, rather than the mostly supportive and enhancing role it takes in Tolkien's world.

Geography

In the Silmarillion (and other histories) we get a clear start-to-finish view of Tolkien's world, including some detailed geography (you can get a brief overview here). This leaves little to no room for a whole new continent (the one the Eragon story takes place in).

Dragons

Dragons in Tolkien's world are massively powerful, difficult to kill, generally evil, and obsessed with wealth. They can also communicate by speaking. Look for example at Smaug in The Hobbit - he's a pretty typical example of a dragon. Dragons were created at least in some fashion by Morgoth (the biggest baddest big bad guy in Tolkien's world), although it's not clear exactly how. There are also relatively few of them. See here.

Dragons in Paolini's world are much more numerous, potentially much more friendly, and communicate telepathically. They are inherently wild and sometimes violent, but not actually evil. After initial conflict, they learn to coexist peaceably with the other sentient beings.

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    Something to add: In the Inheritance Cycle, the elves were originally not immortal, but became immortal through their magical contract with the dragons (which also created the Dragon Riders). In Tolkein's universe elves were immortal from the time they were first created. – MJ713 Nov 29 '17 at 20:15
  • For sure - there are a whole host of differences between the worlds (look at culture, religion, races, etc). I just wanted to highlight a few to illustrate the answer. – Dacromir Nov 29 '17 at 20:33