18

This anime I remember a scene where two normal people can summon a warrior from ancient times and during a battle some girl summons Joan of Arc and some guy summons a character who's ability is to use any sword ever created mythical or real and he fights Joan with the Excalibur

migrated from anime.stackexchange.com Dec 1 '17 at 6:44

This question came from our site for anime and manga fans.

  • 9
    Probably Fate/stay night or Fate/Apocrypha. – Gao Dec 1 '17 at 5:11
  • 1
    In the spirit of scifi.meta.stackexchange.com/q/11552, I've migrated this identification request, which appears to be about a fantasy anime, over from Anime & Manga – senshin Dec 1 '17 at 6:45
  • 5
    In case you ever decide to join us here, knowing when you watched it would help, as well as a few more plot details. You can find more help for adding plot details in this guide – Edlothiad Dec 1 '17 at 6:48
  • 1
    The Fate/Stay series is great and also on Netflix (Canada). Highly recommend. Unlimited Blade Works (Night) and Zero are both awesome; Apocrypha is OK but pretty chaotic due to the sheer number of characters, especially if you've never seen either of the other Fate/Stays. Also, maybe this is just me but I feel like the animation is a little weaker in Apocrypha. – Kalmino Dec 1 '17 at 18:27
29

You are probably thinking of Fate/stay night (or its prequel, Fate/Zero), with a number of details misremembered.

The character who you think is Joan of Arc is actually a genderswapped King Arthur (but until her identity is revealed, people commonly guess that she's Joan of Arc). As such, it is she who uses Excalibur, not her opponents. She is typically called "Saber".

Saber

There are two characters whose ability could be construed as being able to use any sword ever created. One of them (Gilgamesh) literally owns a copy of every weapon in existence and has the ability to summon them using the so-called "Gate of Babylon". The other (Archer) has the ability to create a copy of (almost) any sword he witnesses.

Gilgamesh Archer

What you recall as "pulling swords out of a wall" is probably the Gate of Babylon, which is really more of a "pulling swords out of thin air" sort of thing, but they all tend to emerge from the same vertical plane, so I can see why you'd recall it being a wall.

Gate of Babylon

14

While Senshin's answer ID's both Fate/Stay Night and Fate/Zero the answer focuses on Fate/Stay Night by mentioning Archer and using images of him and Gilgamesh from Fate/Stay Night

I would say however it is actually Fate/Zero

First off Senshin is correct in IDing Gilgamesh and Arturia (The Female King Arthur) however there is are 2 parts in the question which don't match the answer being Fate/Stay Night

The first thing is

some girl summons Joan of Arc

Senshin is correct about the mistaken identity of Arturia being Joan of Arc but this was only in Fate/Zero (in Fate/Stay Night, to my recollection, Joan of Arc is never mentioned). another person who was summoned, Gilles de Rais, who fought with Joan in the 100 Year War mistook Arturia for being Joan

Gilles de RaiJeanne in Fate/Zero

Also, Arturia wasn't summoned by a girl. she was summon by Kiritsugu who is a man (and is summoned by his son Shirou in Fate/Stay Night). however as apart of his plan for fighting in the Holy Grail War Kiritsugu had his wife Irisviel von Einzbern act as if she had summoned Arturia.

Irisviel and Arturia

The second thing is that while Gilgamesh appears in Fate/Stay Night, he was summoned in Fate/Zero and survived until his appearance in Fate/Stay Night (which takes place several years after Fate/Zero).

the person who Gilgamesh follows in Fate/Stay Night, Kirei Kotomine wasn't the one who summoned him but it was Kotomine's "Teacher" Tokiomi, but later in Fate/Zero Gilgamesh sides with Kotomine

Tokiomi and GilgameshKotomine and Gilgamesh

  • 11
    And all that is further complicated by the fact that in Fate/Apocrypha Joan of Arc is actually summoned. – eshier Dec 1 '17 at 14:49
  • 1
    In Fate/Apocrypha is Joan summoned by a female magician? If so, that may warrant a 3rd answer. – KareemElashmawy Dec 1 '17 at 18:34
  • 3
    @KareemElashmawy Nope, Joan is sort of a "special case" in Apocrypha. She doesn't get summoned by a female magician. – Kalmino Dec 1 '17 at 18:38
  • 1
    @KareemElashmawy and to add to what Kalmino said, the second character who can use any sword is Gilgamesh as he brags about having everything ever created (from swords to wine to an ancient airplane) but he doesn't appear in Apocrapha. the only other Fate title with an anime that has both Gilgamesh and "Arturia" is Fate/Extra where Nero looks practically the same as Arturia but Joan is not mentioned and the Fate/Extra anime is actually coming out next year which currently does not look to be following the CCC Routes (Fate/Extra CCC is when Gilgamesh appears) – Memor-X Dec 1 '17 at 20:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy