9

If the Doctor built a paradox machine, he could save anyone and do anything he wanted to do, as the Master did. The paradox machine is powerful enough to let the Toclafane kill their ancestors without causing a massive paradox.

So, why not create a paradox machine?

  • Why not what? I don't understand your question. Why did he not save anyone with it? – Edlothiad Dec 6 '17 at 7:26
  • why not create a paradox machine to do things that he couldn't do?, save people that he couldn't save? – L. Miguel Dec 6 '17 at 7:37
  • And how would he create said paradox machine? Is that something that exists in universe? – Edlothiad Dec 6 '17 at 7:39
  • yeah, it exists, as i said, it was used by the master so the toclafane (future humans) could kill their own ancestors without causing the grandfather paradox. – L. Miguel Dec 6 '17 at 7:40
  • 3
    “he could save anyone and do anything he wanted to do” — absolute power corrupts absolutely. It would be bad. – Paul D. Waite Dec 6 '17 at 8:32
30

There are several reasons The Doctor would decide against building a Paradox Machine:

He doesn't know how

The original Paradox Machine was created by The Master. There's no reason to suspect The Doctor has the knowledge required to build a Paradox Machine at all.

In "The Girl Who Waited" (S6, E10), The Doctor says he can use the TARDIS to sustain a Paradox allowing two Amy Ponds from different time streams to exist simultaneously, but later reveals this to be a lie. This could mean that the TARDIS by itself isn't capable of sustaining the paradox, or that it could, but The Doctor doesn't know how to make it.

He'd have to effectively destroy his TARDIS

In order to construct the Paradox Machine, The Master had to cannibalise the TARDIS, taking different parts and reconstructing them to allow the paradox to occur. So to do the same, The Doctor would have to also modify his TARDIS to the point where it no longer operates as a TARDIS. I don't believe he would ever consider doing that to ol' "Sexy".

It's not a permanent solution

Anything that anyone does while under the influence of a Paradox Machine is reversed the moment the Paradox Machine stops working. In the case of The Master, an entire Earth Year was undone after Jack shot it, and all the Toclafane were sent back to the end of the universe.

So if the Paradox Machine The Doctor builds stops working for whatever reason, be it damage, or a simple malfunction, or even just a companion talking sense into him, anything he does would get undone. He could save every living thing in the universe a million times over and it would get reversed like it never happened, though being at the centre of it he'd still remember everything.

It's too much power

The Doctor has been tempted this kind of power many times before. For example, just in the modern series, he was offered The Skasis Paradigm by Lassar

DOCTOR: I could save everyone.

FINCH: Yes.

DOCTOR: I could stop the war.

"School Reunion" (S2, E3)

He briefly gave in and decided to become The Time Lord, great decider of who lives and who dies, before being slapped round the face with a lesson in morality

DOCTOR: We're not just fighting the Flood, we're fighting time itself. And I'm gonna win!

...

DOCTOR: For a long time now, I thought I was just a survivor, but I'm not. I'm the winner. That's who I am. The Time Lord Victorious.

...

DOCTOR: I've gone too far. Is this it? My death? Is it time?

"The Waters of Mars" (2008-2010 Specials, E3)

And the most recent example, he was given an army of Cyberman by Missy for his birthday

MISSY: An indestructible army to rage across the universe. The more they kill, the more they recruit. Happy birthday. Oh! You didn't know, did you? It's lucky one of us remembers these things.

...

DOCTOR: All of this. All of it, just to give me an army?

MISSY: Well, I don't need one, do I? Armies are for people who think they're right. And nobody thinks they're righter than you. Give a good man firepower, and he'll never run out of people to kill.

DOCTOR: I don't want an army!

MISSY: Well, that's the trouble! Yes, you do! You've always wanted one! All those people suffering in the Dalek camps? Now you can save them. All those bad guys winning all the wars? Go and get the good guys back.

DOCTOR: Nobody can have that power.

"Death in Heaven" (S8, E12)

Ultimately, he always ends up refusing the power, because he realises it's just too much for a single person to have.

In the grand scheme of things, it's kinda rubbish

Of all the various ways The Doctor could become an omnipotent deity ruling over the cosmos, a Paradox Machine is really one of the worst ways he could go about it, even if he wanted to.

I'm sure there are other reasons, but I think it's safe to stop at five.

  • Good answer. I honestly can't remember if the 8th doctor novels are canon at this point, but if so there's one more reason: he spends a lot of that period fighting a faction that explicitly embraces paradox (I think you have to kill your younger self to join, or something; it's been a while) so it might be a personal code of ethics. – tardigrade Dec 6 '17 at 16:34
  • Another problem is the stories would get quite boring. The Paradox Machine could be the answer to just about any problem they run into. – Mast Dec 7 '17 at 2:33
  • Another example would be when the doctor temporarily abosrob the time Vortex, but do not use the power to do anything – Edelk Dec 7 '17 at 8:16
  • Huh, I didn't know about Faction Paradox until now. Neat. I'm not sure about the Time Vortex example. What happens to Nine in Parting of the Ways directly conflicts with what Ten says in Utopia. At the time, absorbing the energy of the time vortex was killing him, so it's entirely possible he wouldn't have been able to do anything with the power anyway. Given the ambiguity, I'm inclined not to include it. It's a good shout though, somehow I'd forgotten about it when I made my answer. #NeverSkipNine – DisturbedNeo Dec 7 '17 at 12:40
9

he could save anyone and do anything he wanted to do

The Doctor himself has had this exact thought once before: during the Tenth Doctor episode "The Waters of Mars".

The deaths of the Bowie Base One astronauts, in particular captain Adelaide Brooke, were a fixed point in time. The Doctor was forced to explain this to them and was about to leave them to their fates, but then he had an epiphany (emphasis mine):

DOCTOR: There are laws, laws of time. And once upon a time there were people in charge of those laws, but they died!. All of them died! And do you know who that leaves? Me! It's taken all these years to realise it, but the laws of time are mine and they will obey me!

Note that that last bit is eerily similar to the Master's catchphrase. Anyway, the Doctor TARDIS'd back into Bowie Base One, rescued the surviving astronauts and brought them back to Earth, and everything was fine, right?

Nope.

The astronauts were actually quite horrified by the Doctor's newfound God complex. Adelaide called him out on it and told him he was wrong to meddle with history, then went home and shot herself in the head, restoring the fixed point. At this point, the Doctor had a second epiphany:

DOCTOR: I've gone too far.

He tried playing God once. It didn't end well. I don't think he'd try doing it again.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.