4

In Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan Admiral Kirk inspecting the Enterprise briefly talks to a young looking person.

KIRK: Ah. And who do we have here?

PRESTON: Midshipman First Class Peter Preston, engineers mate, sir!

KIRK: First training voyage, Mister Preston?

PRESTON: Yes sir!

http://www.chakoteya.net/movies/movie2.html1

And some versions of the movie have Mr. Scott add that Preston is his sister's youngest child.

When I first saw Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan I was rather shocked by how small and thus young Preston looked. Since Starfleet is usually more or less based on the modern US Navy and Preston looked too young for the US Navy I thought he should have been too young for Starfleet.

Then I recognized Peter Preston's actor as Ike Eisenmann and did a little "age computation" to deduce that if Preston was as old as Eisenmann he would have been about 18 and old enough to Starfleet. At the present time the minimum age to enter US service academies or enlist in the armed forces is 17. Of course I still thought that Preston looked a bit short and small to enlist or to enter the Academy, but maybe Starfleet, with its push button warfare style, doesn't need officers or men to be as big and strong as modern armed services do.

Valorum's answer to this question: Is it possible to enroll in Starfleet Academy as an adult?2

begins by saying:

There appears to be no minimum or maximum age at which one can enrol in Starfleet Academy. At the lower end, we see Wesley Crusher and Peter Preston entering the Academy at a very young age (15 and 13 respectively) whereas Garak (who seems to be in his 40's) nearly fools Worf into helping him to apply.

Wesley Crusher takes a highly competitive test to enter Starfleet Academy in "Coming of Age" and he does not get the only open slot at the Academy. I have always figured that they were being tested for a special program that could admit younger than usual persons to the Academy if they were very exceptionally talented, and that the Academy entrance standards were not usually that strict. I have wondered if other Star Trek characters like Spock, Alternate Universe Chekov, and Peter Preston also entered the Academy via that hypothetical special entrance program that might allow persons to enter at a younger age than usual.

In the "The Menagerie Part 1" Commodore Mendez said Captain Pike was injured rescuing cadets during a disaster.

MENDEZ: He went in bringing out all those kids that were still alive. Just wanted you gentlemen to be prepared.

http://www.chakoteya.net/StarTrek/16.htm3

When I first saw the episode I assumed that, like cadets in the 20th century armed forces, the cadets would all be 18 and older, older than me, so they hardly seemed like "kids" to me. But if Peter Preston could be in Starfleet age 14, then it is possible that many persons young enough for me to have considered them kids would have been killed and injured during the disaster.

Khan's followers who were killed aboard the Reliant in TWOK looked like they were mostly in their twenties, but Khan's followers in "Space Seed" should have been forty or fifty by then. Did Khan's followers in "Space Seed" look very young for their ages in TWOK? Were Khan's followers in TWOK the children of his followers in "Space Seed", aged under 15 but looking very mature for their ages? Were Khan's followers in TWOK augmented children who escaped from Earth in 1996 with Khan's adult followers?

And then there was the baby in Khan's group in early scripts, who presumably was vaporized in the Reliant.

We saw only a small sample of the presumably hundreds of cadets and trainees on the Enterprise in tWOK. If the youngest looking one, Peter Preston, was over 18, there would be no reason to believe than any of them were under 18. But if Peter Preston was only 14, some of the other cadets and trainees aboard the Enterprise could also have been that young, and possibly younger.

Thus it is certainly possible to imagine that the battles in TWOK could have been between two ships with a significant proportion of kids in their crews.

So my question is: How old was Peter Preston when he entered Starfleet Academy?

Is Valorum correct to say that Peter Preston was 13 when he entered Starfleet Academy? Was he some other age when he entered Stafleet Academy?

  • 2
    While this is still a valid question, you might want to remove all the references to the other answer as that small error in wording has now been corrected. – Skooba Dec 29 '17 at 19:55
5

The film's official novelisation explicitly states his age as fourteen.

"And who is this?" Kirk said, stopping in front of the child.

Peter drew himself up so straight and serious that Saavik wanted to smile. He was blond and very fair; under the admiral's inspection his face turned bright pink. He was a sweet child, so enthusiastic he practically glowed, so proud to be in space at fourteen that he lived within a radiating sphere of joy that could not help but affect those around him.

Even Saavik.

This tallies with the film's script.

He stops before a BRIGHT-FACED FOURTEEN-YEAR OLD, standing so stiff he looks like he'll break -- in an engineer's uniform.

KIRK: (continuing) And who is this?

PRESTON: (breathless) Midshipman First Class Peter Preston,engineers mate, SIR.


It's never made especially clear whether engineers (and other enlisted personnel) go to Starfleet Academy at all or whether they're trained elsewhere, but the evidence tends to suggest that they go to some sort of technical academy, then ship out as soon as they've completed Basic Training. Depending on how long this training lasts, Peter could potentially have enrolled at thirteen or fourteen.

  • 1
    Valorum - that is a good answer as far as it goes. But is it conclusive? – M. A. Golding Dec 29 '17 at 18:30
  • 2
    @M.A.Golding - It's there in black and white in front of you. How much more conclusive do you want it? – Valorum Dec 29 '17 at 18:33
  • Valorum - that is 100 % conclusive in any fictional universe that includes the novelization. But I believe that the official Star Trek canon includes only the live live action movies and TV shows. I believe that many fans accept the official canon and don't considered novelizations, novels, scripts, comics, etc. as Star Trek canon. – M. A. Golding Dec 29 '17 at 19:08
  • 2
    @M.A.Golding - If the only source you'll accept is the film itself then it's not answerable. – Valorum Dec 29 '17 at 19:29
1

As Valorum points out the novelization of Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan states that Peter Preston was fourteen during the Genesis Incident. This makes it seem very likely that Vonda N. McIntyre used a script or scripts that described Peter as 14, and that nobody told her "Oh, we decided to make Peter Preston older than in the script".

And I have a copy of the script for Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan that describes Peter Preston as 14. I noticed that each page had a date on it, presumably that of the latest revision. So I would guess that Peter Preston's age was still 14 whenever the page with the latest date was revised for the last time.

But was Peter still supposed to be 14 when Ike Eisenmann was hired for the role? Eisenmann was born July 21, 1962. The movie was filmed from November 9, 1981, to January 29, 1982, so Eisenmann was 19 when his scenes were filmed. Thus it was legal for him to work longer hours than an actor under 18.

So I have to wonder if Ike Eisenmann was hired to portray a 14-year-old or someone near his own age.

  • I believe that many fans accept the official canon and don't considered novelizations, novels, scripts, comics, etc. as Star Trek canon – Valorum Dec 29 '17 at 19:29
  • The novelization and the script show that Peter Preston was originally supposed to be 14. But was Ike Eisenmann hired to portray a 14-year-old Peter Preston who looked old for his age or was he hired to portray an 18-year-old or older Peter Preston who looked small and young for his age? – M. A. Golding Dec 31 '17 at 7:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.