At the end of the film Gillian is concerned that the whales won't have air, but they were already in an enclosed Plexiglass compartment.

How did the whales breathe in the compartment?


2 Answers 2


The film's official novelisation indicates that there was a sizeable air-gap at the top of the tank, more than enough for the whales to breathe on their short journey, even if that air wasn't being recycled by the ship's life-support systems (which it almost certainly was).

Fighting the instinct to breathe, Jim kicked through the deep water. He broke the surface and flung up his arm to fend off the ceiling. The sprung seals had allowed most of the air to escape. Only a hands-breadth of airspace remained between the water and the top of the cargo bay. Gasping, treading water, he tilted his head back so his nose and mouth remained in the air. He took a long, deep breath, and dove again.

This concurs nicely with the film's shooting script.


[Kirk breaks the surface, his lungs screaming for air. Only a few inches remain unflooded. He gulps air, and dives one last time.]


According to this site

On average, adult humpbacks surface every 7-15 minutes to breathe but can remain submerged for up to 45 minutes.

That said, there probably wasn't a lot of air in the tank but it was for a short trip to the sun and back with the idea being that the whales would be released into San Francisco Bay upon arrival in the 23rd century.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.