I'm trying to recall the name of a science fiction short story about a missionary who tries to preach to an alien whose language consists not of words but of chemical diffusion gradients.

The alien species is like a pool of liquid on the ground, and the priest tries to figure out how to translate sermons or scripture into its language.

  • Welcome to the site. You have a good start here. If you could take a look at this guide to help jog your memory and edit in any more details, that would be great. Every little bit helps us.
    – amflare
    Feb 28, 2018 at 17:19
  • 1
    Did the aliens end up crucifying the missionary on the theory that if there were anything to his message that God would resurrect him? Feb 28, 2018 at 20:25
  • 2
    I've got this one on my shelf at home. If no one beats me to it I'll provide a high information-density signal with the good news later on. Feb 28, 2018 at 20:47

1 Answer 1


Pretty good odds that you are looking for Ken McLeod's 2005 short-story "A Case of Consilience". (After a James Blish story of very similar title, with which is shares some parallels.)

The story follows Rev. Donald MacIntyre's attempts to reconcile his missionary zeal with the constraints of the purposefully multi-cultural nature of the Extra-Terrestrial Contact Station.

In particular he is interested in a kind of

'underground fungoid a hundred meters across that communicates by chemical gradients'.

Scientists from the station have a tentative, partial translation of the signaling system, and one recorded signal seems to Donald to be a confession that these creatures know sin in the Christian sense of the word.

Station intelligence is concerned that Donald might attempt to violate rules on preferential cultural access. We pick up the action when he is next on the surface of the planet in question and approaches the mud patch between two of the fungiod colonies, in which the chemical gradients could be measured in transit.

'Donald stepped to the edge of the mud and set up the apparatus the team had devised for non-intrusive examination of the mycoid's messages [...].

'There as a small experiment he had been given to perform. It had been done many times before, to no effect. Perhaps this variant would be different. He reached into his pocket and pulled out the plastic covered gel-disc [...]. The concentric circles of molecular concentration that covered it spelled out—the team had hoped—the message "We wish to communicate. Please respond."

'Donald peeled off the cover [...]. He stuffed the crumpled wrappings in his pocket and reached in deeper for a second disc: one he'd covertly prepared with a different message.*

At this point security appears and talks him down, but he falls into the mud—which turns out to be quicksand. In the end he is not rescued due to circumstance beyond human control and dies there.

The rest is a rather major spoiler:

The mycoids find the layering of chemical information that is the late Donald MacIntyre much more interesting than the boring low-bandwidth messages the science team had been sending. They record all that he knew and read the GOOD NEWS therein.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.