3

In Rogue One, we see Jyn Erso being transported by a HAVw A9 Juggernaut to the Imperial labor camp when the Rebels rescue her.

Assuming that the A9 is about the same size as the A6, then it should be massive and well armed. The 5 or 6 rebels we see attack it should have been dead.

How did the Rebels stop the Juggernaut?

  • 4
    Maybe they had, you know, a super cool Imperial security droid to flag it down for them and draw the crew out? – Wiggo the Wookie Apr 5 '18 at 20:08
3

Apparently the Rebel Alliance wanted to keep it a secret because the procedure has not been revealed in detail. It must have been a well-planned and successful ambush of some kind since nothing ominous can be seen in front of the Juggernaut(s), in either the movie or the graphic novel adaptation.

enter image description here

enter image description here

It's possible the Rebel agents tricked the transport(s) to stop pretending to be another prisoner pick-up. Maybe K-2SO played a role here. At least this was the first impression of the stormtroopers.

"What now?"

"I don't know. Must be another pick-up."

"I thought we had everybody."

Anyhow, the Juggernaut(s) were not stopped by force, but the Rebels initially used some sort of stealth tactics instead. The screen in the comic book shows there's no superficial damage on either one of the tanks.

enter image description here

Interestingly there were two turbo tanks in the graphic novel, as the movie gave an impression of there being only one. Given that, Jyn was most likely held in the first one, which means that the Rebels must have stopped and controlled them both.

-3

It seems obvious that the script writers didn't consider the size of the tank and simply used it because it looks cool and has wheels.

Stopping the tank and pointing a pistol at the driver's window would have resulted in a snort and possibly a snicker from the tank's crew, so they just skipped this part.

Then again, maybe the rebels had ewoks...when in doubt, blame the ewoks it always works. No need to actually work for your a clever film script after all. The fans will buy a ticket anyway.

  • 1
    This answer is quite offensive towards the script writers and directors and makes no effort to answer the actual question. I'll remind you that the be nice policy covers all people. – TheLethalCarrot Apr 13 '18 at 8:24
  • I was being nice. The Rule of Cool is a Hollywood trademark for a reason. – Pef Apr 13 '18 at 10:24
  • The last paragraph isn't exactly nice. The first paragraph is borderline depending on how it's worded. Though to be honest I don't see how this scene is "Rule of Cool" at all. – TheLethalCarrot Apr 13 '18 at 10:27
  • Welcome to Science Fiction & Fantasy! However, some of your answers (such as this one) have not been well received and don't really answer the question (e.g. this one is mostly speculation). Please review the help center -- especially how to write a good answer to learn how this site works. – Null Apr 13 '18 at 13:46

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.