6

Millenium Falcon chased by a Star Destroyer. How will they get out of this one?

I was thinking about one of the major plot points in “The Empire Strikes Back” (1980) which was tracking down the Rebels and capturing Luke Skywalker.

So when the Imperial fleet attacks the Rebels on Hoth, Rebel ships of all kind are flying all over the place with the intention of regrouping later once they are safe.

Knowing this, then what was the in universe rationale for Darth Vader’s fleet focusing on the Millennium Falcon? Why would he assume that the Millennium Falcon would contain Luke Skywalker or friends that could help lead them to Luke Skywalker?

Of course for out of universe reasons, the Millennium Falcon is iconic and the ship that typically has contained the heroes of the saga. And one can assume that Darth Vader members the Millennium Falcon from the actions on Death Star. But still… It seems a bit too OCD.

Looking for an answer with clear references; canon or “Legends” please. No armchair speculation please.

13

Vader thinks that Luke is on it.

“Asteroids don’t concern me, Admiral,” Vader said as he slowly clenched his fist. “I want that ship, not excuses. How long until you will have Skywalker and the others in the Millennium Falcon?”

Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back - Official Novelisation

He assumes (erroneously) that Luke would be with his friends during the evacuation.


There's also the fact that Solo and the Falcon were instrumental (along with Luke) in destroying the Emperor's shiny new toy, although it's made clear later in the film that Vader mostly cares about Solo and Leia as a route to Luke.

Without turning his head, Vader snarled through his mask, “The Millennium Falcon?”
Piett paused a moment before replying. He would have preferred to avoid that issue. “Our tracking scanners are on it now,” he responded a bit fearfully. Vader turned to face the admiral, his towering figure looming over the frightened officer. Piett felt a chill course through his veins, and when the Dark Lord spoke again his voice conveyed an image of the dreadful fate that would be inflicted if his commands were not executed.
“I want that ship,” he hissed.

Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back - Official Novelisation

3

At no point in the movie does Vader tell the Imperial officers that he believes Luke is on board the Falcon. I've not read the novel, but I do think we must only be concerned with the actual movie.

In the movies, it is made very clear that Vader can sense Luke's presence when Luke is nearby. In Star Wars he can sense the presence of Luke during the attack on the Death Star ("The Force is strong with this one", he says, in the combat above the Death Star).

And in Return of the Jedi, Vader detects Luke's presence on board the stolen Imperial Shuttle Tyderium, during the approach to the Moon of Endor.

So it is simply not possible to include a scene in TESB in which Vader can express uncertainty as to whether Luke is aboard the Falcon. That would have undermined a key part of the powers Vader has from the Force, upon which the events of Return of the Jedi will depend.

In the movie TESB, Vader's motive is very clear: he wants to capture Han and the Princess, because by torturing them he can send a message to Luke, via the Force, which will draw Luke to him. He knows they are Luke's friends. He knows Luke will sense their pain through the Force.

There is actually a scene, in Cloud City, of Han being tortured. Han is baffled as to why this is happening, because they ask him no questions. But we, the audience, seen Luke's reaction, far away on Dagobah, when he feels the danger which Han and Leia are in.

Vader is solely interested in the occupants of the Falcon because they are Luke's friends, and can be used to draw Luke into a trap. And in one scene, we see Vader obtaining the Emperor's permission to try to turn Luke or to kill him, so we know that the Emperor considers Luke a significant threat, one that must be neutralised.

Later, we learn too that Vader had also a hidden motive for desiring to find Luke, as he has come to realise that Luke is his son.

  • Not a bad theory, but when you say, “In Star Wars he can sense the presence of Luke during the attack on the Death Star.…” Err… He sensed “The Force is strong with this one…” and not specifically Luke. And in “The Empire Strikes Back” the Force connection only shows up near the end between Luke and Leia and then Vader and Luke… By the time “Return of the Jedi” came out a lot of these events were retconned, but when—for example—Luke reached out to Leia with the force it was just showing his connection and ability to use the force to contact others. But yeah, it almost gels. Will +1 this. – JakeGould May 7 '18 at 1:20
  • In Star Wars, when the Millennium Falcon arrives on the Death Star, Vader says (to Peter Cushing) that he senses the presence of his old teacher, Obi Wan Kenobi. This is the first intimation in the film that Vader can sense the presence of other Jedi through the Force. This power is later reinforced by Vader's comment the force is strong with this one regarding Luke (who he has not yet met). Obviously he does not know Luke by name, since they never meet in the film. But Vader's ability to detect the presence of Kenobi proves that he can identify individual Jedi previously known to him. – Ed999 May 8 '18 at 6:32
  • You say, “In Star Wars, when the Millennium Falcon arrives on the Death Star, Vader says (to Peter Cushing) that he senses the presence of his old teacher, Obi Wan Kenobi.” But he doesn’t say anything about Ben Kenobi. He simply says, “I sense something. A presence I’ve not felt since...” In the context of the film it could have meant Kenobi or someone who has a strong connection to the Force. Heck, it could have meant Luke since—as we know from next movie—Luke is his son. Being able to sense someone with a connection to the Force is one thing; being able to sense a specific person is another – JakeGould May 8 '18 at 15:07
  • I interpret "a presence" as meaning a particular individual - not a generalized effect (like "a Jedi Knight"). He may be struggling to put a name to the feeling, but I've always understood that as meaning he knew Obi Wan was near. – Martin Bonner Jul 10 '18 at 20:35

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.