From my earliest watching of Star Wars, I remember distinctly that Ben Kenobi's home on Tatooine wasn't a Tunisian domed house that we know from the movie, but a cave cut out of the rock itself.

The establishing shot was one of the Petra caves, looking something like this

enter image description here

After decades of talking to people and being greeted by blank stares, I casually brought it up to a guy who remembered the same thing.

Given the n^2 versions of Star Wars out there, was there a version of a New Hope that had this alternate "Kenobi's Home" or is this a bizarre and rare shared halucination?

  • 1
    I seem to recall that he originally went to live in a cave, but eventually moved to a proper house, but I can't find a reference of it. – Max Apr 27 '18 at 20:38
  • 3
    could be conflating w/ the novelization which placed has his home in a cave – NKCampbell Apr 27 '18 at 20:55
  • 4
    @NKCampbell - "Trying to watch the surrounding rocks and his footsteps simultaneously, Luke fought to drag Threepio clear of the pit. The decor of Ben Kenobi’s well-concealed cave was Spartan without appearing uncomfortable. It would not have suited most people, reflecting as it did its owner’s peculiarly eclectic tastes. The living area radiated an aura of lean comfort with more importance attached to mental comforts than those of the awkward human body." - Worthy of its own answer, perhaps? – Valorum Apr 27 '18 at 21:02
  • 3
    Not shared hallucination but shared fake memory. And it is not rare, it is in fact quite common. It's called the Mandela effect (from the fact that a lot of people swear they remember seeing or reading about Nelson Mandela's funeral while he was still alive) – slebetman Apr 28 '18 at 1:27
  • 2
    I remember this too for what it's worth – tox123 Apr 28 '18 at 1:38

Editing and montage makes you think that Kenobi lives in a cave

It is a well known fact that editing saved "New Hope" from being a very poor movie, maybe even worse then "Last Jedi" :D Unfortunately some things had to be cut, so we have a story with very sharp transitions in some parts, and Kenobi's house is one of them.

First, there is a part where old Ben saves Luke from Sand People in front of some caves. We were never shown how Kenobi got there, implying that he lives near by.

enter image description here

Next we have brief look at Kenobi's house. Unfortunately this is sudden, the trip to it is never shown, and after that we have an indoor scene - a very important one where Kenobi talks about the Jedi and Luke's father, Leia appears in a message, Luke mulls should he go with Kenobi or return home ... Therefore, people tend to forget this shot:

enter image description here

Also note that the walls in Kenobi's house are very rough, so it's hard to discern if this a house or a modified cave.

enter image description here

Luke makes the decision he is not coming with Kenobi. Movie cuts to Imperials and after that comes a scene where Luke and Kenobi discover dead Jawas. Again, it is never shown how did they get there, subconsciously implying that Obi-Wan and Luke didn't go far. Scenery in this scene resembles the scenery in the first scene (Sand People attack and rescue). So a casual viewer would conclude that after Kenobi saved Luke they simply hid in one of the caves (Kenobi's home) and after a while they emerged only to find the Jawas attacked and killed.

enter image description here

  • Ben and Luke outside of the cave MIGHT have been it... I remember the door as door shaped, but this makes the most sense to me so far. – OhkaBaka Apr 30 '18 at 20:44

After the first time I saw Star Wars (on an early print that did not say "A New Hope"), I thought I remembered the scene where they watch Leia's message taking place in a cave. However, when I saw the movie again, a few years later, I realized that I have gotten the video message scene confabulated with the events in the desert after Luke gets knocked out by the Sand People, and R2-D2 is watching from a hollow in the nearby rocks.

My best guess is that you had the same kind of confusion.

  • R2-D2 watching from that hollow was my first thought, looking at the picture. We are introduced to Ben mere seconds after that. – Mazura Apr 28 '18 at 0:30

Could you be getting confused with the cave that Luke uses to make his lightsaber in this (pretty famous) deleted scene from Return of the Jedi?

enter image description here

  • You say the scene's from Empire Strikes Back, the video clip seems to be from RotJ? – RDFozz Apr 27 '18 at 20:44
  • 2
    @RDFozz - That's the sort of thing that you should just go right ahead and edit. – Valorum Apr 27 '18 at 20:49
  • 1
    Funnily enough, part of that clip (with Vader seated in his sphere) is almost certainly reused footage that was originally shot for The Empire Strikes Back. – Buzz Apr 27 '18 at 22:20
  • 1
    @Valorum Who in their right mind would trust their own judgement of an answer of yours enough to edit it without asking you? – jpmc26 Apr 28 '18 at 3:21
  • @JPMC - If it's a really obvious mistake, anyone and everyone should feel free to edit it – Valorum Apr 28 '18 at 6:53

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.