33

Recently I noticed this oddly specific pose, which I am now dubbing the Super Hero Holds Two Things Together Pose (or SHHTTTP for short), has appeared from what I can tell at least six times in the MCU, possibly more.

Thor keeping the forge open on Nedavallir

Spider-Man holding two ships together

The first known instance of the SHHTTTP, Captain America holding a helicopter down in Civil War.

You will of course notice that I only have three pictured instances of the SHHTTTP here, well the three others I've noticed I couldn't find pictures for, but that definitely do exist are: Gamora keeping Drax tethered to the ship in GOTG Vol 2, Spider-Man keeping Doctor Strange from being abducted by the flying doughnut in Infinity War and Thanos being briefly restrained by both arms in the battle on Τitan (also in Infinity War).

Obviously there is no in-universe explanation for why this is so common, however is there an out-of-universe explanation? Does Kevin Feige just really like pectoral muscles or something? Am I just insane and seeing patterns where there are none?

Any other known examples of the SHHTTTP in Superhero media would also be very much appreciated.

  • 29
    +1 for "Wackiest question subject that, in the end, I really couldn't argue with." – gowenfawr May 30 '18 at 21:35
  • 12
  • 10
    @Valorum From that page: "The "person with outstretched arms symbolically representing Christ" pose is so deeply ingrained into modern culture that anytime we see a character in that pose, we tend to assume the director was going for this trope, even when it's obvious from the context of the scene that he or she wasn't". Did the director mean to say that Captain America died for our sins? You make the call! – Thunderforge May 30 '18 at 21:55
  • 19
    There is an in-universe explanation: The heroes just keep having to hold two things together. – ThePopMachine May 30 '18 at 22:09
  • 10
    Why not? Massive biceps: Check. Struggling on both sides: Check. Slow-motion view of the hero using all of their force to overcome a challenge: Check. – Möoz May 30 '18 at 22:15
7

I'm not sure 6+ instances from around 48 hours of footage is "prevalent". There are far more superman like poses, or people standing, leaning on things, even sitting, but we don't look for meaning in those.

As one of the comments said (and really they should take all the credit), there just happens to be scenes where things had to be held together (or pulled apart) where legs can't be on the ground, showing that even though this character had good like super immense strength for whatever [origin] reason, is still giving their all to try to save humanity (or vogonity if there is any sign of poetry), because succeeding is more important than pain when the universe is at stake.

I think you're looking for a reason that isn't there. If it was in every film, and maybe more than once in some films, or if it was always the same character then I'd say you're on to something. But there are far more other stances that are far more prevalent with little to know reason.

Even Deadpool made fun of how painful and impractical the main landing stance of an average superhero is.

But this is just my opinion, i can't back it up with any facts whatsoever

6

The SHHTTTP is a subcategory of a common trope in many films: the crucified hero pose.

It's very common for a character who just performed a Heroic Sacrifice to be lying with their arms outstretched like the crucified Jesus.

Note that characters who stand with outstretched arms aren't necessarily meant to represent this pose; they can also symbolise bird wings, in the sense of freedom. Or angel wings, as a mix of both.

See the above link for a list of examples, but the movie that made me start looking for this pose everywhere was the Matrix.

Any other known examples of the SHHTTTP in Superhero media would also be very much appreciated.

The link above contains a list of a bunch of superhero comics and movies. Here are a few examples I can think of:

  • 1
    "Crucified", yes, but I would not say the three last ones are "holding two things together"... – Jenayah Aug 1 '18 at 18:01
  • 1
    @Jenayah I don't disagree with you. I guess I'd say the SHHTTTP is a subset of the jesus pose. – Kevin Workman Aug 1 '18 at 18:03
0

The pose demonstrates the hero's heroic willpower while also looking cool

The SHHTTTP is difficult, painful, static, and optional. In most cases the hero in this pose is suffering, but the suffering is entirely voluntary because the hero is capable of letting go at any moment.

This means that the hero, in addition to showing off their immense strength also demonstrates how heroic they are. Punching villains is all well and good, but rarely causes the heroes pain (generally it's the other way around). Getting beat up is generally not voluntary, and doesn't show off the hero's strength.

Having the hero protect a person or object from an oncoming attack can have a similar effect, but it's a lot harder to produce a long tracking shot of a high speed collision. (That said, you do get at least one example in Infinity War, when Captain America holds Thanos' fist open). Holding two things together is generally static (the whole point is to keep the objects from moving after all), so it lends itself to long dramatic shots.

(A lot of the symbolism I've described here applies to the Crucified Hero shot in general, but it's strongest in this particular pose.)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.