2

The Harry Potter books mention that the Weasleys had a clock telling them the status of various family members (work, hospital, mortal peril, etc.). At one point after Voldemort's return, all of them are listed as being perpetually in mortal peril. For example:

‘Then you just buck up your ideas, young man, before I decide you’re too immature to come with us!’ said Mrs Weasley angrily, snatching up her clock, all nine hands of which were still pointing at mortal peril, and balancing it on top of a pile of just-laundered towels. ‘And that goes for returning to Hogwarts, as well!’

Ron turned to stare incredulously at Harry as his mother hoisted the laundry basket and the teetering clock into her arms and stormed out of the room.

-Half-Blood Prince - Chapter 6: Draco's Detour

Wouldn't that significantly diminish the usefulness of the clock? After all, wouldn't it be possible for someone to be in greater or lesser degree of peril? Wouldn't they want to know if someone was in particularly grave danger (e.g. an imminent battle with the Death Eaters)?

Also, wouldn't you want to know their secondary status? For example, you could both be in the hospital and in mortal peril (recall the guy who was murdered at St. Mungo's in the 5th book), but the clock doesn't seem to be able to represent that.

closed as primarily opinion-based by JohnP, tilley31, TheLethalCarrot, Dave Johnson, Blackwood Jun 11 '18 at 14:08

Many good questions generate some degree of opinion based on expert experience, but answers to this question will tend to be almost entirely based on opinions, rather than facts, references, or specific expertise. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • Well, as long as the clock's reading that way you know the war's still on... – EvilSnack Nov 24 '18 at 4:03
6

The clock doesn't show "mortal peril" at all times. It still has usefulness.

‘It’s been like that for a while now,’ said Mrs Weasley, in an unconvincingly casual voice, ‘ever since You-Know-Who came back into the open. I suppose everybody’s in mortal peril now … I don’t think it can be just our family … but I don’t know anyone else who’s got a clock like this, so I can’t check. Oh!’ With a sudden exclamation she pointed at the clock’s face. Mr Weasley’s hand had switched to travelling.

Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.