I'm looking for a fanfiction story based on the Lucifer TV-show. I probably read it on ArchiveOfOurOwn, but it may also been elsewhere.

In the story, angels who wanted to help a human to conceive a special child had to sacrifice something divine — for Jesus, the angel sacrificed (part of) his little finger... which he was still missing.

It turns out that Lucifer lost a feather (or two) in the gates when he was kicked out of Heaven — and this was used to conceive Chloe, or possibly Trixie. Either way, Chloe's previous contact with Lucifer's divinity is what makes her immune to him.

Lucifer does not take the news of his "fatherhood" well.

I think Lucifer is given the second feather.

I think it was Aminadel who used the feather.

So does this sound familiar? Does anyone remember the title and author? (And maybe have it saved?)

PS: I actually think it was Trixie, and she's some kind of prophet... or maybe I'm mixing with another story.

  • Can you give us a rough time-frame of when you read this? Was it in the past year? Roughly how long was it ( a short story/novel length/UBER long). Was it in English? Are there any other phrases/scenes that stand out to you?
    – Sensoray
    Commented Jul 23, 2018 at 14:58

1 Answer 1


Found it!

It was "Chosen One" by PokerFace84:


Takes place after season 1 final. Lucifer's mother is out of Hell, hiding and plotting... something. Meanwhile a new very odd case turns up, a handsome new detective is hired by the police department and Trixie gets into real troubles going beyond this world. And then there are these stupid feelings... Can one Devil solve all this and live to tell the tale?

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.