I'm looking for the name of a series of books (and/or their author), written in English. The storyline followed the last surviving members of a race(?) of people with magic powers corresponding to the classical four elements, residing in an otherwise typical fantasy world. I think there was some kind of church organization that condemned these people to death if found.

The first book followed a young woman with "water" powers, which translated primarily into being able to heal people. The memorable feature is that for the main character, employing her healing power required her to square off on some kind of spiritual plane with a sea serpent-like monster representing death. The first book opens with her living a solitary existence on the edge of the sea and occasionally healing people. The second book involved the heroine of the first book finding and taking charge of a young girl with fire powers. The second book at least left open the possibility of a third book, but I never read it, and don't recall noticing if it had been published.

Other random clues: I read the first two volumes some time around 2008, although if I had to guess they were probably written in the 90s. Fairly sure the author was female, and likely near the beginning or end of the alphabet (I got the books from the library; I have a visual memory of picking them up from one end of the sci-fi/fantasy shelves, which would have the beginning of the alphabet on one side and the end on the other). I think cover of the first book featured a woman fighting a sea serpent.

EDIT: Some further details I can recall (partly because they differ from the first answer I got): The first book definitely featured only a water person. Besides the fire girl mentioned above, an earth person appears around the end of book 2. Fairly sure all the magic people were female, though whether that was part of the worldbuilding or just coincidence, I don't know. I do remember that whatever wiped out the magic people happened a while in the past of the story, and the land was currently at peace. The first book had some kind of typical romantic subplot between the water heroine and the local prince/duke/male-royalty-person. This would seem to rule out the Elemental Logic series pointed out in one answer, which based on descriptions appears to feature a variety of LGBT relationships (which is cool, but doesn't match my recollection of this particular series).

  • Welcome to Science Fiction & Fantasy! This question would be improved by going through the checklists here; How to ask a good story-ID question? – Valorum Jul 20 '18 at 20:35
  • I've been through much of this list but did not find a match. Still, might be worth taking a look to see if your book is in there :) – Jenayah Sep 23 '18 at 12:56

Sounds like it could be the series Elemental Logic. It’s Earth powers that heal, but the summary for the series sounds similar:

“The Elemental Logic series is set in the world of Shaftal. Some 35 years prior to the first book, Shaftal was invaded by an army of Sainnites who, in an attempt to eradicate the magic which might be used against them, killed all the elemental witches they could locate. However they failed to realise that magic is inherent in the Shaftali and children have been born since who can wield it. Furthermore, the Sainnites have become cut off from their homeland and are subject to constant guerilla action from the Shaftali. Among both the learned, peace-loving Shaftali and the warlike, spartan Sainnites, women and men are equals in all things, including military, and both queer and polyamorous/polygamous relationships are common and accepted.”

  • Fairly certain that's not it, although there's definitely some similarities. This answer makes me realize/remember some details that I didn't add initially--my apologies! – rsandler Jul 21 '18 at 14:07

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.