I just finished reading The Dark Forest, second part of the Remembrance of Earth's Past trilogy.

My question is, (spoiler alert):

When the droplet finally made it to Earth, why did it chose not to kill Luo Ji, and instead settle on the Lagrange point?

It seems like it could have done away with him once and for all. A related question is why were the Tri-Solarans so obsessed with him – we never got an answer to that.

(I have just started Death's End additional context).

  • 1
    The obsession is because he was the only unbroken Wallfacer and then the Sword Holder. He was literally the most important person on Earth to the Tri-Solarians because he was the only one who initially understood the nature of The Dark Forest.
    – Jontia
    Commented Nov 14, 2018 at 11:09
  • 2
    @Jontia or at least, the Trisolarans KNEW he understood it, and knew he was empowered to use that knowledge strategically. Commented Dec 14, 2018 at 13:00

3 Answers 3


[This answer is based on books 1 & 2 - and not any information from Death's End].

TLDR: My interpretation is that the droplet was never sent to kill Luo Ji. It was sent to interfere with Earth strategems based on "dark forest" principles, only reaching Earth centuries after Luo Ji was expected to have died already.

But Luo Ji himself was confused about this, believing for years that the probes were in fact sent for him. The use of his confusion was a clever element of the book's written style and plot.

Consider when & why the droplet was sent...

Ye Wenjie shared her formation of the basic principles of cosmic sociology with Luo Ji. Even though at that time Luo Ji had no understanding of the consequences of those principles the Trisolarans recognized that information as a risk -- anticipating that the "dark forest" principle would eventually be understood by humans. (Learned this via the sophons of course.)

The Trisolarans set both a short and long term plan in motion immediately after that event. This was the first time since establishing the sophon block that a serious, unexpected threat was identified in humanity. A threat which could manifest itself even given the sophon block, and long before their main fleet could reach Earth.

The short-range plan was to order the assassination of Luo Ji. An attempt was made on his life even before he was made a Wallfacer, and of course other attempts followed. The purpose of this policy was to try and eradicate the genesis of the dark forest concept before Luo Ji could even understand it or spread it. Assassination had the potential of preventing or at least significantly delaying humanity's realization of cosmic sociology and the development of strategies to counter Trisolarans based upon it.

(They could have tried to kill Ye as well, being the only other human known to Trisolaris to have this information. On the other hand they may have still regarded her as an ally).

The long-range plan was to get the 10 probes (including the droplet) to Earth as soon as possible. The 10 probes of the Trisolaran fleet began their acceleration towards earth as soon as Luo Ji learned of Ye's principles. Clearly this was not a part of the original invasion plan, and presumably the fleet must have made some compromises in order to make the probe's advance possible. This is evidence of the high level of risk the Trisolarans perceived.

However at that time the Trisolarans had no way of knowing what the conditions would be on Earth when the probes would arrive ~200 years later. In particular they couldn't know that Luo Ji would even still be alive at that time. So it seems clear that the intention of sending the probes was to give them the earliest possible opportunity to stave off any threat posed by humanity, including a strategy based on dark forest principles. But not to kill Luo Ji specifically.

But after the human fleet's destruction as the droplet approached the inner solar system Luo Ji certainly thought it was after him. This is understandable for several reasons. Firstly he had already escaped Trisolaran assassination something like 8-10 times, so he was justifiably paranoid. Secondly, he knew for a fact that the droplet began accelerating as soon as he learned of the dark forest principles. (Learned from Ranier, I think?) (*)

But this fear on his part was an element of the excellent storytelling. The droplet was never sent to kill him, specifically, but instead it fulfilled its mission by (1) annihilating the human fleet, and (2) instituting the block of using the sun as an amplifier.

This seems to be rich irony. With the solar block in place the Trisolarans felt they had defeated Luo Ji's plan - that he could never send a second signal to the universe beaconing the locations of Earth & Trisolaris which so threatened them. And yet this was also their downfall because they indeed should have eliminated him before he ultimately executed his brilliant checkmate and nullified all their own strategems.

Luo Ji had in fact embodied the Wallfacer principle perfectly, being strategic yet unreadable, duplicitous, and misdirecting. The Trisolarans viewed him as a threat only as a conduit of the dark forest; but in actuality he himself was the threat.

(*) No one other than Luo Ji knew of the coincident timing of the probes' acceleration and his conversation with Ye.



From the end of Dark Forest (spoiler alert):

"Two centuries ago, Rey Diaz was not a threat to us, nor were the other two Wallfacers. We transferred our contempt for them onto you."

"...we thought you were just using the meaningless task as a way to escape reality."

"In the end, strategy was where we failed."

The Trisolarans saw how Luo Ji cast his "spell" the first time, and block his means to do so a second time. They likely view him as now neutralized, and they already view humanity as bugs.

Note: I've also only just started reading Death's End.


It's quite obvious. Luo Ji requested an audience with sophon and, as a final stand, announced two things: 1) he had rigged nuclear bombs to announce the location of Trisolaris and Earth 2) he had a dead man's switch. We should assume sophon now knows of the dead man's switch because of Rey Diaz. If the droplet killed Luo Ji, it would reveal their coordinates and that would be mutually assured annihilation.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.