8

In The Great Hunt, Fain is freed from his cell in Fal Dara by an unspecified person.

Now, before anyone says "Isn't it obvious?", let's analyse the scene in question.

The door to the outer guardroom opened, spilling in a flood of light, darkly outlining a figure in the doorway.

Fain stood. "You! Not who I expected."

The Great Hunt

It's suggested later on by Loial that it was Nidao and Changu who, corrupted by Fain who had been corrupted by the Shadar Logath dagger, helped him escape. However, we already know that Nidao and Changu had been corrupted much earlier on, noted by Rand when he and Egwene visit Fain. If they were already corrupted prior to that, why would Fain not expect them to help free him?

Secondly, with have Liandrin, whose POV is right before Fain's escape.

Full night already, and there was much to do before dawn. Her orders had been explicit.

What orders? Freeing Fain? Helping the Darkfriends steal the Horn? Spying on the Amrylin? The real reason she's a likely suspect is because of the placement of her POV, which makes me think, immediately after reading about her orders, that she is the one who freed Fain.

Lastly, Ingtar the Darkfriend. We know that it was he who let the Gray Man in, but it's never really mentioned if it was him who freed Fain, or not. He's my most likely suspect; consider this scene:

Rand was shocked, but Loial explained softly. "Shienarians believe we all came from the earth, and must return to earth. [...] And there are never any words except 'The Light shine on you, and the Creator shelter you. The last embrace of the mother welcome you home.' " Loial sighed and shook his huge head. "I do not think anyone will say them this time. No matter what Ingtar says, Rand, there cannot be much doubt that Changu and Nidao slew the guards at the Dog Gate and let the Darkfriends into the keep. It had to be they who were responsible for all of it.

And Ingtar surprises everyone by saying those words on their graves, giving the reason that it was because "they saved Lord Agelmar at Tarwin's Gap".

Or another reason, perhaps because it was him who freed Fain, and (as we know if we're on a re-read) he has already begun to forsake the Shadow again when the Darkfriends stole the Horn, and feels bad for Nidao and Changu taking the blame, so he says the words.


In the reputable WOT:Encyclopedia, footnote 5 of Shadow of Shienar states that it was Ingtar who freed Fain. as confirmed by RJ.

In an interview, Robert Jordan stated that Ingtar was the one who freed Fain. As the cell is dark, it seems that this scene depicts the arrival of Mat and Egwene. (TGH,Ch6)

However it's not sourced, leaving it ambiguous yet again as to who freed Fain.

So, my question is, Who was it that freed Fain in Fal Dara?

It would be great if anyone can find that particular fore-mentioned interview, or any other WoG from the author(s).

4
  • 3
    There was also a dark prophecy scribbled on the walls, which they seem to believe had been written by a Myr'draal. So a Myr'draal was somehow involved too? Also another suspect is Verin, though she seemed genuinely surprised to find the prophecy there. Whoever did it was likely acting on direct/indirect orders from Ishamael. Ingtar's regrets throughout the whole book makes him the most likely culprit indeed. Fain would be surprised getting rescued by Ingtar, Liandrin or Verin but perhaps not by a Myr'draal.
    – Amarth
    Jan 1, 2019 at 13:38
  • 1
    I don't have any new "evidence" to contribute in a real Answer. I can only say that the second time I read TGH, I took it for granted that Ingtar must be the mysterious person who opened the door for Padan Fain in that scene. I had not heard if Jordan had ever confirmed (or denied) that.
    – Lorendiac
    Jan 1, 2019 at 15:50
  • 1
    Same question on Google Groups, without any conclusive answer.
    – Rand al'Thor
    Feb 12, 2019 at 8:31
  • The battle's never over, @Rand al'Thor!
    – xdhmoore
    Jul 18 at 5:51

1 Answer 1

5

Word of God confirms that it was indeed Ingtar who freed Fain from the cell. The full interview can be found here

WOTMANIA
Did Ingtar free Padan Fain in The Great Hunt? Or was it someone else?

ROBERT JORDAN
It was Ingtar. Didn't expect a straight answer, did you?

Interview on Theoryland when searching for "Ingtar Fain"

1
  • Nice find. Can't argue with WoG.
    – Voronwé
    Aug 28, 2020 at 14:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.