I can think of two times in the TV show when a White Walker has essentially caught a human, and then just let them walk away.

  1. The survivor from the Night's Watch in the first episode.
  2. Samwell Tarly at the Fist of the First Men when he was too slow to run away.

Is there ever any explanation or evidence why the White Walkers would let lone humans escape?


2 Answers 2


As per the books, the events went differently.

Will was on a tree when the Others killed his commander Ser Waymar Royce. After Royce was dead and the Others left, Will climbed down. But once he was down, he was assaulted by the walking corpse (Wight) of Ser Waymar Royce. Will never survived the attack. It was Gared, the third guy they left with the horses, who escaped. Gared already had a feeling that something very wrong was afoot but he was ignored by his young Commander. Since he was at a safe distance already when the Others did for Ser Waymar, he escaped, aided by the fact that he had horses. There's no information on how exactly did he escape except that he was arrested south of the Wall and executed by Lord Eddard Stark.

As for Sam, Sam never encountered the Others like he did in the show. He was present at the Battle of the Fist of the First men where the Night's Watch escaped with the Lord Commander personally leading the cavalry charge which broke the undead lines. After that it was a long retreat back to the Wall. They lost many men to sporadic attacks from the Others, sickness and cold but they eventually made it to Craster's Keep. Once there, the mutiny happened and honest men made their own way to the Wall, Sam included. He did face one Wight (formerly known as Night's Watch man Small Paul) and killed him with the dragonglass dagger that Jon had given him but that was before the mutiny. Sam was attacked once more by Wights after the mutiny when he was escaping the mutineers with Gilly. Sam killed one of them but he was beset by more Wights. He was saved and escorted to the Wall by Coldhands.

So no, in answer to your question, in the books at least the Walkers don't deliberately leave survivors. Some people like Gared or the NW men at Fist of the First men, however, manage to escape with sheer luck or desperate courage.


The White Walkers never saw Sam

First impression says that Sam and the White Walker make eye contact with each other. However, we see Sam hiding behind a rock in a previous scene, indicating that he was able to wait out the White Walker and escape.

It could also be pretty big jab at Sam. He was so pathetic as his father suggested that even the White walkers didn’t want to kill him. If the White walkers truly didn’t kill him for being pathetic, it would be ironic when Sam’s wisdom ends up being their demise. Sam's dragonglass discovery lends credence to this theory.

Will left his companions to die

In the fight with the White Walkers, Will says that his companions were brutally killed by White Walkers and he was the only survivor. This indicates that he legged it while leaving the others to die. He was lucky not get a javelin in his back while running away.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.