22

At the end of Deep Space Nine, Season 2, Episode 23 - Crossover (which takes place in the Mirror Universe) Prime Universe Dr. Bashir is fleeing from Mirror Universe Odo and Bashir shoots him with a Bajoran phaser.

Odo promptly explodes like a water ballon.

My question is, what happens to Odo when he is hit by a phaser? Did he actually die (the others seem to think so ...) should he really have exploded into jello?

One thinks of later episodes where phaser sweeps are used to find Changelings (however, on stun.)

The scene in question ...

enter image description here

enter image description here

enter image description here

15

It is specifically mentioned in "Chimera" that metal weapons (in this case a dagger) cannot hurt a changeling. From this it is easy to deduce that other weapons CAN hurt a changeling.

Considering how a phaser works (it fires "nadion particles"), the weapon most likely has an effect on what it hits quite different from the effects of a bullet or other non-energy weapon. Whatever "nadion particles" do when they hit matter that isn't a gas, they obviously would do it to shapehifters too. We see solids die when hit by a phaser beam, but we don't usually see them lose a specific limb or whatever is hit. The effect is apparently common to the entire body hit.

"Extreme Measures" tells us that nadion particles were also tried as a tool to cure Odo's disease (they didn't work). Since the disease affected the entire body it is unlikely the particles were meant to "cut" through a specific part of it. They clearly affected the entire body or at least the body mass surrounding the impact zone.

So clearly Odo died when hit by a phaser set to kill. There is no reason to assume that he didn't. (It was also confirmed by a Klingon on the station.)

  • 1
    +1 for the mention of "nadion particles" ... its a good step into trying to explode the exploding water ballon Odo. – Justin Jenkins Jul 13 '12 at 6:45
10

Mirror Universe Odo is speculated to have indeed died during the uprising, killed by our Julian Bashir using a Bajoran phaser. He appears to be shattered by the phaser. At least one Klingon confirms Odo's death.

Such a shattering would not normally have been thought to harm a changeling since our universe's Odo was able to recover from being dropped and shattered. (DS9: Vortex) To be fair, our Odo was merely dropped. He was not shot with a phaser.

We must assume there was something different about the Mirror Universe Odo, or perhaps the difference was in the phaser being used. A Bajoran phaser would have likely had a stronger kill setting since it would be used against armored Cardassians and/or possibly Klingons.

The Mirror Odo might have simply been caught unaware during the thorium leak and riot and unable to compensate for the charge of the weapon. Even though the Changeling physiology is more flexible and resilient than a human's it make sense he would need some time to prepare to be able to redirect the energy of the phaser reducing the damage to himself.

  • "caught unawares and unable to compensate" Seems reasonable, as does a more powerful phaser (since this is the 'evil' mirror universe after all.) Setting aside the idea that the producers just went for some (bad) dramatic affect ... it fully doesn't really explain why he exploded the way he did. – Justin Jenkins Jul 12 '12 at 8:56
3

I think he just exploded due to the sudden temperature/pressure change (a bit like popcorn), but he didn't die. Although I don't have a quote for this ready, I assume changelings don't possess anything like organs (they just fake them, like eyes), considering how different they might appear. So even if some part of him was destroyed by the phaser, it could be just like losing an arm or a leg, it just doesn't matter where that body part has been, as all "cells" (if you're able to call them like that) might take any position.

Also, if you consider some warp-capable species treating them as gods, I don't think they'd do so, if a single phaser could take them out (someone would have tried it at some point in time i assume).

Edot: Also another idea: If changelings are able to fake things like fire, they probably could fake explosions as well. Given their "liquid" nature, I wouldn't expect them to die just due to parts of their body being separated for a while (otherwise something like the Great Link would be odd to me as well).

  • "treating them as gods" ... exactly, that seems odd to me too, even if you assume perhaps some level of cultural god-status had been set about before the avent of phaser type weapons, you'd think someone would have tried it. – Justin Jenkins Jul 12 '12 at 8:58
  • 3
    The species that treat shapeshifters as gods are those created or modified by the founders. Dominion species don't know who the founders are and merely fear the Dominion's power. Pre- and non-dominion species never treated the shapeshifters as anything but vermin, certainly not as gods. (The exception were the early Vorta who treated at least one shapeshifter like a person.) – Andrew J. Brehm Jul 12 '12 at 9:40
0

Mirror Universe Odo carried a phaser because he was a sadistic mofo who put no value on the lives of terran slaves. Now that that's out of the way, the changelings were physiologically speaking kind of like an organic version of the T-1,000 from Terminator 2; bullets or blades might pass through them harmlessly but energy weapons like a phaser are a different matter (to quote precedent, 'female' changeling told Odo in the past 'solid' lifeforms killed some changelings out of fear; also the one impersonating General Martok died under a hail of disruptor fire shortly after being exposed). Assuming changelings are affected by stun settings (not all aliens are), one could logiacally expect it to force them into their 'true' form but render them incapable of taking action.

-1

Phaser works by stopping the electron spin in atoms, therefore, matter disintegrates by the loss of atomic bonds. This is the same as disruptors, which are similar to phasers, but more crude and uncontrolled. In "Chimera" the other changeling claimed the Klingon was going for his disruptor, hence it was self defense. In "The Ship", the changeling on board of the Jem Haddar ship eventually dies because of injuries when the ship lost its dampening fields. In "The Search" they were using phaser sweeps to disrupt the changeling's abilities to keep shape.

  • 2
    The first part of this answer is pretty solid. You might want to try editing it to focus a bit more closely on the question asked. – Valorum Oct 22 '14 at 19:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.