6

I just read the answers to a question related to talking patronuses (Was Shacklebolt's Patronus the only one that spoke?).

One thing I am always bothered by in relation to this is the question I am asking here. (I am not considering the more obvious things to do in similar situation, so let's ignore those for now; e.g. Send 1 of the kids (Harry or Hermione, Ron was injured) under the cloak/ Wait till morning and then send 1 of the kids/ Stun Pettigrew, etc.)

I will clear some assumptions that I am making here:

  1. Lupin knew how to make a talking patronus: Lupin was an order member with considerable knowledge about patronuses, if Kingsley and Arthur Weasley could do it, I am pretty certain Lupin knew how to do the talking patronus magic.
  2. Dumbledore could understand Lupin's patronus and knew enough about the Shrieking Shack: This is pretty clear from the books that Dumbledore knew the entrance to the Shack.
  3. The patronus does not keep blabbing until it gets to the desired person/location: So nobody else can figure it out except Dumbledore.

So why did they have to go strolling in the moonlight instead of just waiting for Dumbledore to arrive?

  • 4
    I would assume that Lupin had simply forgotten that it was full moon. – Harry Johnston Jan 28 at 5:27
  • 4
    @HarryJohnston Lupin is a werewolf, his whole life revolves around the full moon, it is the thing he fears most. He would never forget the full moon. He would also never forget the wolfsbane potion. – QuestionAuthority Jan 28 at 6:42
  • 3
    Maybe this was a simple plot hole overlooked by J K Rowling. Sometimes that is the best answer to these "Why didn't blah happen when it would have been so easy?" kinds of questions. – LincolnMan Jan 28 at 8:01
  • 6
    ... out of universe, talking Patronuses presumably hadn't been invented yet. – Harry Johnston Jan 28 at 8:48
  • 4
    +1 for @HarryJohnston out of universe answer. Every talking Patronus in your related question appears in GoF or after. – F.Carette Jan 28 at 9:03
1

It is likely, Lupin forgot about the coming full moon. If the full moon was not coming that very day, he did not need outside help to do what was planned - to present Sirius to Dumbledore in person, apprehend Pettigrew as a proof of Sirius's innocence, and help Harry and Hermione to take injured Ron to the castle, where he could receive help.

At the time he faced the full moon and realized his mistake, it was too late, the transformation has already started. I doubt it is possible to do any magic at this state.

From Harry Potter and the Prizoner of Azkaban, Chapter 20

A cloud shifted. There were suddenly dim shadows on the ground. Their party was bathed in moonlight. Snape collided with Lupin, Pettigrew, and Ron, who had stopped abruptly. Black froze. He flung out one arm to make Harry and Hermione stop.

Harry could see Lupin’s silhouette. He had gone rigid. Then his limbs began to shake.

“Oh, my —” Hermione gasped. “He didn’t take his potion tonight! He’s not safe!”

Out of Universe, as HarryJohnston has said in comments, Patronuses were not yet introduced as a method of communications.

  • Not only is the moon cycle of critical importance for a werewolf, Snape had been there and told them that Remus didn't take his potion. Even if he managed to forget before, that was another reminder of the full moon. The out of universe explanation is that Harry was supposed to be given hope for a better life with Sirius (anybody but the Dursleys), only to have that hope crushed.. – QuestionAuthority Jan 28 at 19:49
  • 2
    @QuestionAuthority, having given it some more thought, I'm not convinced this is quite as unrealistic as you suggest. Lupin has gotten out of the habit of having to fear the days of full moon, because he has access to the potion which he can take instead. And he's too focused on Peter and Sirius to remember that he hasn't taken it yet, and anticipate the consequences of that. Granted Snape just reminded them, but under the circumstances it isn't surprising that they might not be paying close attention to that sort of detail. – Harry Johnston Jan 28 at 23:25
  • 1
    ... also, he made it all the way to the Shack without going were. Perhaps he just figured he had a few hours left before he had to worry. – Harry Johnston Jan 28 at 23:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.