6

After reading this question it made me wonder: are there any instances where the illustrations in the Illustrated Harry Potter series contradict known book canon?

  • 2
    Would you count portraits? Because there are many Easter eggs one of which I have asked a question about here – Niffler Apr 2 at 22:36
1

Update: I misunderstood the question. (I did not realize it was supposed to be about the illustrated editions, specifically.) However, I am leaving this answer for posterity.

The covers of the first American editions of the seven Harry Potter novels all depict events that occur in the books (albeit with some graphical distortion and extra stuff going on in the background)—except for the cover of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire

It can actually be quite jarring to look at this cover, side by side with Mary GrandPré's other covers. Rather than depicting any kind of action scene from the book, this one is just a collage of imagery. It shows the four participants in the Triwizard Tournament, all together inside the hedge maze, along with a number of other iconic elements from the plot—a panorama that never occurs in the story.

I presume that the reason for change in the art was not a creative decision by Ms. GrandPré, but that it was likely mandated by the publisher. Goblet of Fire was the first Harry Potter book to come out after they had become a huge international sensation, and the executives appear to have mandated that the protagonist should be present and more centrally located in the cover art from that point forward. For the fifth, sixth, and seventh volumes, though, the cover illustrations are back to being action scenes from the stories, although the keep Harry himself large and near the center of the picture.

  • I'm downvoting, because although this is a great naswer, you edited my question (I assume unintentionally) to ask what I didn't mean to ask. I was only referring to the oficial illustrated editions. – TheAsh Jul 7 at 2:36
  • 1
    @TheAsh Oh, sorry about that. I didn't mean to change the meaning of your question. – Buzz Jul 7 at 5:25
  • and with the edit comes an upvote. Enjoy. – TheAsh Jul 7 at 13:43

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.