-5

I'd like to write about attitudes taken toward the prime directive in Star Trek, potentially including all of the TV series within the original timeline (esp. OS, TNG, VOY, DSP), and need some touchstone episodes on which to base my conclusions. Recognizing that the prime directive is an overriding theme that can be related to almost any episode in any series (it is, after all, "prime" ...) I'll narrow that down:

What shortlist of Star Trek episodes deal most explicitly and continuously and with a moral conflict that arises directly in reaction to a consequence of the Prime Directive, in the context of a technologically advanced people (i.e. Starfleet) encountering a primitive or powerless people, and feeling compelled to intervene, whether due to moral or political interests? And with the crux of the episode turning on whether the prime directive is followed or ignored?

More informally, high quality writing, big stakes, interesting real world political analogues, and iconicism within Star Trek fandom lore are all other good criteria.

closed as off-topic by DavidW, Valorum, Robert Columbia, TheLethalCarrot, Rand al'Thor Apr 8 at 14:02

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

  • "Requests for lists of works or recommendations are off-topic as they do not fit our questions and answers format. Feel free to ask about people's favorites in chat." – Robert Columbia, TheLethalCarrot, Rand al'Thor
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • Hi, welcome to SF&F! Because of how the site works, questions asking for a list of answers don't tend to work well. You should check out How to Ask and questions to avoid asking. You might want to try re-wording the question to focus on specific instances where the Prime Directive was followed or ignored. – DavidW Apr 8 at 13:38
  • @DavidW: Good thought, thanks. Is the above what you meant, and are there any further edits I should make to keep the criteria narrow and clear enough? – Flux Apr 8 at 13:41
  • What might work is an appeal to authority, asking if there are episodes indicated by the producers, actors, directors, Gene Roddenberry, etc, as good examples of the Prime Directive. That way, there's an authoritative answer, and one researchable. – FuzzyBoots Apr 8 at 13:47
  • 2
    The TNG episodes "First Contact" and "Who Watches the Watchers" are two that jump out at me immediately. – Xantec Apr 8 at 13:51
1

The shortest of short lists: "A Private Little War" (TOS). This episode deals with the Prime Directive, tells us Kirk's history understanding it and upholding it during his first planetary survey as a young Lieutenant in Star Fleet, and shows us what can happen when it is challenged (by the Klingons, who hold no such principle). This episode shows Kirk struggling with the Prime Directive, tempted to match the Klingons in supplying the Hill People weapon for weapon to level the playing field. It paints historical context for the PD, referencing Earth history with relevant precedent and consequences. In the end, he makes a typical end-justifies-the-means decision, considering the PD already broken due to the Klingons' actions. Even as he makes that decision, he knows he is supplying, as he puts it, "Serpents for the garden of Eden".

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.