Lets say you had 3 wizards, let’s call them A, B and C. If A were to turn B & C into Horcruxes, B were to turn A & C into Horcruxes and C were to turn A & B into Horcruxes. Would killing wizard A destroy the Horcruxes B & C had placed on them or would the Horcruxes remain due to a fragment of A’s soul existing in B & C? Hence making all 3 immortal unless they were killed simultaneously.

  • I closed your question as a duplicate because it seems to be essentially the same question that was already asked. If it's not, you can edit to clarify what you are asking that is not covered by that question. – Alex Apr 17 '19 at 0:46
  • Possible duplicate of What makes a Horcrux object (almost) indestructible? – Möoz Apr 17 '19 at 5:17
  • There's a fact-based answer below... – Alex Apr 17 '19 at 6:01

Once a body dies, the Horcruxes in it die.

Three wizards who make each other into Horcruxes wouldn’t become immortal. Since creating Horcruxes doesn’t make the body indestructible, their bodies would still be able to be killed.

“Well, you split your soul, you see,’ said Slughorn, ‘and hide part of it in an object outside the body. Then, even if one’s body is attacked or destroyed, one cannot die, for part of the soul remains earthbound and undamaged. But, of course, existence in such a form …”
- Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, Chapter 23 (Horcruxes)

By killing Wizard A’s body, Wizard A would become bodiless and Wizard B’s and Wizard C’s Horcruxes in that body would be destroyed, since Horcruxes aren’t able to survive the destruction of their container.

“But my point is that whatever happens to your body, your soul will survive, untouched,’ said Hermione. ‘But it’s the other way round with a Horcrux. The fragment of soul inside it depends on its container, its enchanted body, for survival. It can’t exist without it.”
- Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Chapter 6 (The Ghoul in Pyjamas)

Then, killing Wizard B would make Wizard B bodiless, destroy one of Wizard A’s Horcruxes and destroy Wizard C’s last Horcrux, making Wizard C entirely mortal again. Killing Wizard C would then, in addition to killing Wizard C permanently, destroy Wizard A’s and Wizard B’s last Horcrux, leaving both Wizard A and Wizard B mortal. Ripping Wizard A and Wizard B from their bodies wouldn’t have been enough to destroy them, since would be able to create new bodies like the Dark Lord did, but all of their Horcruxes would be destroyed since the bodies housing them were destroyed, so they’d be mortal and able to be killed if they created new bodies.

| improve this answer | |
  • And all of this under the assumption that a container can hold 2 soul fragments simultaneously. I don't think we have precedent for that. – user1129682 Apr 17 '19 at 5:18
  • 1
    @user1129682 Harry contained his own soul plus a piece of the Dark Lord’s, so it should be possible. – Mal Apr 17 '19 at 5:59
  • And Nagini was herself and Voldemort. While there may have been multiple souls in the same body, these are not instances where a living being becomes a Horcrux twice – user1129682 Apr 17 '19 at 8:33
  • Might be worth mentioning that Nagini's death destroyed that Horcrux vs. her body being destroyed as well (e.g. I don't have to kill and destroy the body). – neverendingqs Apr 17 '19 at 14:53

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.