3

At the series finale we learn that the North remains

an independent kingdom and that the Seven Kingdoms get renamed to the Six Kingdoms.

The Wall is the northern border of the North. And following the above it is

not in the Six Kingdoms anymore. So the King of the Six Kingdoms has no power over the Wall and the Nights Watch, because they don't belong to his realm.

How can the King send people to the Wall while it is not in his kingdom? And what could he do if they decide to stay in the North with Sansa instead?

  • There will be alternate arragements and the insist on close cooperation with "the realm" – user1129682 May 21 at 8:54
12

Your premise is flawed. Neither The Wall or the Watch are a part of the North. They answer to no Kings and owe no fealty to anyone.

Before the Conquest, Watch was manned collectively by men of all the Kingdoms. It still is. It is the shield that guards the realms of men, it doesn't guard one realm and owes no allegiance to any realm. It serves everyone and protects everyone.

If you want an explicit example, Princess Nymeria sent her six rival Kings to the wall in golden chains once she completed her conquest and brought whole Dorne under the rule of House Nymeros-Martell. Needless to say, North as an Independent Kingdom existed back then and the Wall was definitely not in Principality of Dorne's control.

Of course as you say, Sansa can try and pry away Jon, and Jon can try to escape. After all, Aegor Rivers, commonly known as 'Bittersteel' was rescued when his ship en-route to the Watch was intercepted by his friends. But will Sansa commit such a dishonourable act? Brandon will be forced to enforce his will or his word would count for less. Will Jon be willing to do that? He never wanted anything to do with the politics and administration, he's going home for all he cares. And if Jon does desert or escape, Sansa will have to execute him/hand him back to the watch if he deserts, try to capture him if he escapes. Otherwise Stark honour means for less.

And What happens if the Word reaches the Unsullied that they were played for a fool and their Queen's murderer now sits beside his sister in Winterfell? You can expect Yara Greyjoy, who sided openly with Greyworm, would definitely make sure that the word does reach them. With Ironborn descending from the West and Unsullied from the East, North would be smashed even if Bran takes no hand. Doing so will also give Yara the allies she needs to win her independence with fire and steel after Sansa tricked them all into accepting her brother as King, in case she resents that and wishes to fulfil her father's mission. Giving Jon refuge will:

  1. Dishonour Starks
  2. Make Sansa look weak and unjust
  3. Put the North in risk of a conflict with the Six Kingdoms and the Unsullied.

And you forget, as Tyrion said, Half the country hates people who betrayed Daenerys. Jon would always be at risk of assassination down south by Targaryen loyalists.

1

The Night’s Watch didn’t belong to the Seven Kingdoms either. It’s physically next to the North, but it owes no allegiance to the North, or to anyone. So it should make no difference. The northern border of the North as a political entity is the edge of the New Gift, fifty leagues south of the Wall.

Remember, the Night’s Watch is eight thousand years old and the Seven Kingdoms as a unified political entity lasted for a bit over 300 of those years.

  • so what's the difference with just exiling someone? – Jungkook May 21 at 7:17
  • 1
    I guess the difference is that they at least get to remain in Westeros, a familiar land. They presumably, potentially, still get to maintain some contact with their families, which might not be possible if they were exiled to a different continent. It's arguably also viewed as less dishonourable to spend your life in servitude to the kingdom than accepting exile. – delinear May 21 at 8:29
  • 1
    @Jungkook They’re serving under military discipline and can’t wander freely round foreign countries seeking allies and stirring up trouble. – Mike Scott May 21 at 8:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.