Frodo, Sam, and Gollum are on their way to Mordor when they are captured by Faramir's company. Before releasing them, Faramir takes them to Osgiliath.

In "movie time", the journey to Osgiliath seems instantaneous. However, they probably traveled a distance that the movie just didn't show.

Where exactly were they when they were captured?

Is there a name (or rough location) for the cliff where they watched the Oliphaunts?

  • Osgiliath is nowhere near the south-west corner of Mordor. It is on the road from Minas Tirith to Minas Morgul. Are you mixing it up with Pelargir? Also note that in the book, Faramir does not take Frodo and Sam to Osgiliath (Faramir is much wiser in the book than in the films). – Ian Thompson 2 days ago
  • perhaps South-West is an exaggeration. it's in the middle of the Western Mountain Range. that's still significantly more South than the Black Gate, which is near the North-West corner, but on the Northern Mountain Range. – LevenTrek 2 days ago
  • 1
    re. "It seems unlikely that Frodo and Sam would journey as far South as Osgiliath, given that they were aiming for the Black Gate.": When they met Faramir, they had already seen the Black Gate and had found it to be impenetrable, and had decided to instead try their luck near Minas Tirith (which is as far south as Osgiliath). So they were indeed on purpose travelling as far south as Osgiliath, along the western border of Mordor. – oliver 2 days ago
  • @oliver you're totally right. I got my timing wrong. I'll edit my question accordingly – LevenTrek 2 days ago

Roughly, about ten miles upstream from the waterfall at Henneth Annûn.

A slight correction to your assumptions: There is no cliff from which Sam watches the (single) Oliphaunt. Instead, Sam climbs a tree and watches the Rangers' fight with the Haradrim, including the Mûmak, from there. This was one of the bay trees "close by" the bed of fern "a little way back above" the "small clear lake in a shallow dell" where Frodo and Sam made camp, and where Sam made the cookfire whose smoke was spotted by Faramir and his men. This was "less than ten miles" from Henneth Annûn where Faramir marched them to for the night.

In The Atlas of Middle-Earth, it's a little easier to see this on the detail map of Henneth Annûn than the overview map of Sam and Frodo's path. It's labeled "burned circle". Karen Wynn Fonstad is correct in placing Henneth Annûn downstream from the pool: They come to a gorge which "was the same stream that trickled far above out of the round pool". After which they are blindfolded and follow the river to the refuge.

However, KWF's depiction of this stretch of stream as straight is a simplification caused by insufficient information. Faramir leads Frodo and Sam through thick woods, so the stream and the gorge it drops into might follow a more crooked path than that.

(All quotes come from the chapters "Of Herbs and Stewed Rabbit" and "The Window on the West" from Book IV of The Two Towers, but they are too fragmentary so I'm foregiong the traditional blockquote and hand-drawn red circle. We can piece the rough location together out of the quotes).

  • 1
    And don't forget that Frodo and Sam were blindfolded so the only (and that marginal) knowledge they had as to where they were was distance rather than direction, and that's of course easy to confuse by for example walking in circles – jwenting Jun 13 at 4:01
  • Die verlinkte Karte ist leider beschriftet in Deutsch. Suchen Sie „Versengter Kreis“.... – Spencer Jun 13 at 4:09
  • Yes, I have an older (I think first edition) of the atlas. As you can see on the map, the path is shown as pretty much a straight line. Whether it was truly such Frodo and Sam can't have known as they were blindfolded. Henneth Annun may well have been a bit to the left or right of where it is on the map as a result for example. – jwenting Jun 13 at 4:18
  • 1
    @jwenting They were only blindfolded for a short distance, at the end of the hike, during which the sound of the falls grew steadily louder. But you're correct. Anyway, I don't know who Faramir thought he was fooling, for an outdoorsy hobbit like Frodo, having been there once, would have known to follow the stream downriver then follow his ears. – Spencer Jun 13 at 4:27
  • 1
    @smcs Everything happened before the French Revolution, after all. – Spencer 2 days ago

In the book The Two Towers, Faramir does not "capture" the hobbits and certainly does not force them to travel with him. However, he does meet them and convey them to the a hidden Gondorian sanctuary where they can rest. No name is given in the book for the location where Faramir's men first locate the travelers, nor to the nearby location where the rangers of Ithilien defeat the men and elephants coming from Harad.

Nor is there any location name given in The Atlas of Middle Earth by Karen Wynn Fonstad. The Atlas of Middle Earth is a painstaking effort to produce a set of maps consistent with Tolkien's vision of Middle Earth; it is intended to be used as a reading companion for the books. Had there been a place name for the spot where the men and hobbits met on March 7, Fonstad almost certainly would have included it on at least one of the maps that cover that part of the story. However, there is no place name on any of them. Take, for instance, this map showing the dates of Frodo's and Sam's travel through the realms of Ithilien and Mordor.

Map of Ithilien

Another map from the Atlas shows the name and location of the hidden shelter of Henneth Annûn, but again there is no name for where the skirmish took place.

Another Map

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.