5

Ever since I’ve encountered XKCD 270, over a decade ago, I’ve been fascinated by the idea of T. H. White’s Merlyn.

I’ve now started reading The Once and Future King, and it occurred to me that Merlyn’s “backwards living” might never get properly developed in any of the five books in the series.

A quick web search seems to suggest it is never really explored beyond mentioning it exists. Is that the case? Is there a story arc in any of the books where this way of experiencing time is explored in depth? If so, in which book? And if not, is there any book (possibly science fiction) that expands this idea of Merlyn’s experience of time?

5

It is never spelled out in much detail what it is like for Merlyn to experience living backwards in time. The story begins with a few vague allusions to Merlyn knowing and understanding things that he would not be expected to, by virtue of having seen them before; but initially, it is not clear to the reader by what mechanism he has seen the future already. However, he soon explains his situation to Arthur in chapter 3 of The Sword in the Stone:

I was unfortunately born at the wrong end of time, and I have to live backwards from in front, while surrounded by a lot of people living forwards from behind.

This explains that the wizard's hazy knowledge of the future is really him remembering things that he has already seen.

However, the haziness of Merlyn's future knowledge is often an important factor. He has seen much of the future, but he does not do a particularly good job of recognizing when he has reached a crucial juncture, often arriving to impart his foresight only after the point at which it would be useful. (From Merlyn's viewpoint, this may mean that he actually speaks up too early, rather than too late, but I do not recall that oddity ever being dwelt upon.) His haziness is also thematically tied to his long sleep, into which he he knows he will be placed by Nimue's spell. He is always anticipating and dwelling upon his upcoming ensorcellment (the fallout of his failed romance with Nimue), and seems to be metaphysically groggy throughout much of the narrative.

Matters are further confused by White's explicit use of anachronisms to give the story a better atmosphere. Very early in The Sword in the Stone, Sir Ector is described as drinking port, which the narration admits is not really port, but describing it as port should give the reader the right idea; and it is stated that anachronistic substitutions will henceforth be used whenever it will be useful, based on what the reader is expected to be familiar with. (In fact, the whole Anglo-Norman setting of the story seems to be one such anachronism, since the High Middle Ages are a more familiar setting to most readers than sixth-century post-Roman Britain.) One further consequence of the story's heavy use of anachronistic elements is that when Merlyn mentions something ostensibly from the future, it is sometimes unclear to the reader whether what he is talking about is supposed to be familiar to Arthur or not.

All of these factors combine to make Merlyn a very confusing character, both for the other characters in the narrative (especially Arthur, who pays by far the most attention to Merlyn early on) and for the reader. This all seems to be intentional on White's part, and it is very hard to get a clear idea of what life is like for Merlyn himself; the wizard remains, appropriately, an enigma.

Incidentally, if you are a fan of White's Merlyn, then I would recommend reading the originally published 1938 standalone version of The Sword in the Stone, rather than the abridged version that White incorporated into 1958's The Once and Future King. Several episodes from the wizard's training of young Wart are cut in The Once and Future King, and I think it is better to read them at the points in the story where they originally appeared, although there is also another major episode that only appears in the 1958 version.

  • Well, that was real quick! – Mithoron Jul 15 at 23:40
2

And if not, is there any book (possibly science fiction) that expands this idea of Merlyn’s experience of time?

Living backwards in time is a concept used in a number of sci-fi books. While I haven't seen any that closely resembles whatever we are told of Merlyn's experience in White's books, there is an interesting exposition of the idea in a book by renowned Soviet sci-fi authors, brothers Strugatsky, in their novel "Monday begins on Saturday" (The title of the book has nothing to do with time travel or living backwards in time).

In one of the final episodes of the novel, the protagonists (scientists in a Soviet research institute of magic) observe that the boss of the institute, among other things, appears to know a lot about what is going to happen, but is strangely absentminded about things of recent past.

In the end they think that the boss must be living backwards in time. But, if he were simply living backwards in time, he would appear to be moving physically backwards when he walks, "undrinking" drinks, "uneating" food and talking gibberish. Which is not the case.

After a lot of deduction they come to conclusion that he lives every day normally, but moves backwards 48h every midnight.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.