25

When Khan first defeats Admiral Kirk, he asks about Project Genesis.

Why would he ask about Project Genesis?

Wouldn't the USS Reliant, a ship dedicated to helping the Genesis scientists, have far more information in its computers? Khan used the Ceti eels to control Captain Terrell's mind. He could just order Captain Terrell to give Khan access to the computers.

If Khan did have access to the memory files on the USS Reliant, he would not need to ask Admiral Kirk. In asking Admiral Kirk, Khan revealed his intentions, which a super-genius probably would not do. He also alerted Kirk to go to the science outpost, Regula I, since that is where the Genesis scientists did their research.

What happened when Khan beamed up to the USS Reliant that kept him from getting access to the computer memory files on Project Genesis?

Please provide answers from official sources.

  • 3
    This reminds me of the premise behind the first season of The Last Ship. When they were in the Arctic, the captain and everyone else on the ship knew nothing about the true reason behind the scientists' mission. The scientists knew and a few higher-ups in Washington, DC knew. The mission was on a need-to-know basis and apparently the captain and crew providing logistical support to them didn't need to know. – Jeeped Aug 23 at 5:39
31

The crew of the Reliant were kept on a strictly need-to-know basis about Project Genesis. They were given enough info to do their jobs with safety, but nothing more than that.

Khan questioned Terrell only briefly, but it seemed to give him great pleasure to extract information from Chekov. By the time he finished, he knew each tiny detail of what precious little anyone on Reliant had been told about the classified Project Genesis. He knew where they had been, he knew where they were going, and he knew they reported to Dr. Carol Marcus.

Wrath of Khan: Official Novelisation

When he interrogated Chekov, he learned that Kirk would have access to the full Project Genesis files.

With an edge in his voice, Khan asked, "Could he find out about it?"

Kirk was a member of the Fleet General Staff; he had access to any classified information he cared to look up. Chekov tried desperately to keep that knowledge from Khan Singh. His mind was working so fast and well that he knew, without any doubt, what Khan planned. He knew it and he feared it.

"Answer me, Mr. Chekov."

"Yes."

Wrath of Khan: Official Novelisation

  • I'd guess that even if the crew knew and/or revealed that the Genesis project was rapid terraforming, Khan (in his mental state) might have assumed that there is more behind it (namely a new secret weapon of mass destruction). If everyone told him it's about terraforming, he'd dismiss that and keep torturing until they would tell him the expected "truth" - or die. Then he'd assume that his is all about need-to-know and try to get hold of a responsible Admiral .. (Wait? The admiral's name is Kirk?!) – Hagen von Eitzen Aug 25 at 10:39
  • 2
    @HagenvonEitzen - Also, the ship's crew are unlikely to understand more than the basics of how it works. For that, you need schematics and diagrams and manuals. Heck, the Spanish Inquisition could torture me for weeks and I couldn't tell them how a motherboard works, despite using one daily. – Valorum Aug 25 at 11:15
26

Valorum's answer is good - but, keep in mind, Khan does try to get the information first from Regula:

First, Khan learns about Genesis (as well as Kirk) from Chekov and Terrell:

KHAN: You didn't expect to find me. You thought this was Ceti Alpha Six! Why are you here? ...Why are you here? ...Why? …

So Khan heads to the Regula station to retrieve it / the device.

But - The crew of the space station wouldn't give up the data

TERRELL: He tortured those people. But none of those people would tell him anything. He went wild. He slit their throats. He wanted to tear the place apart, but he was late. He had to get back to Reliant in time to blow you to bits.

Khan asked Kirk about it because Khan had failed to get it from the scientists, and as we see (and as Valorum shows from the novelization), Kirk is an Admiral and he literally has eyes-only access to the Genesis material:

enter image description here

  • Leads to the question: Why didn't Khan bring some Ceti Eels with him to make the Regula scientists more compliant? – Jesse C. Slicer Aug 23 at 17:26
  • maybe he did @JesseC.Slicer - we see Terrell was able to resist a command that was so dissonant with what he believed was right or wrong. Perhaps the scientists had such a strong will in regards to giving up the info that Terrell did in not toasting Kirk – NKCampbell Aug 23 at 18:12
  • 2
    @JesseC.Slicer in the film we only see 3 eels: The "mother eel" and the two "baby eels". We don't see anything that suggest that Khan has more eels than that – SpacePhoenix Aug 23 at 18:22
8

One important thing to keep in mind is that the entire plot of the movie is Khan getting revenge on Kirk, and everything should be seen through that lens.

He makes multiple tactical and strategic errors once he realizes that Kirk is in his grasp. Kirk says it's two dimensional thinking, and the like, but Khan's crew catches him in multiple errors... Which he ignores or rebuts with his need for revenge.

The whole successful conclusion of the movie depends on Kirk reeling in Khan with revenge.

From trusting intercepted communications at face value, to letting his guard down when the prefix code is used, to killing the station crew in rage... Khan shows himself to be blinded by revenge.

Forcing Kirk to give up the data is just another form of revenge, with the bonus that it's way easier than doing the hard work himself.

1

Regular 1's computers had been wipe clean by David Marcus. So no info there. Reliant had only little need to know basic. Kirk had little info, just the basic proposal sent to Star Fleet by Carol Marcus, for the funding of the project. David Marcus had all the information in his head, because he had designed and created the project. But being his father's son he cheated. He used unstable material to accelerate the process that was genesis.

  • 3
    Could you edit I some evidence to back up your points? – TheLethalCarrot Aug 23 at 22:26
  • David used unstable protomatter as part of the Genesis Matrix which is at least part of the reason the Gensis tore itself apart. It couldn't have help that the reorganised matter was from a nebula instead of a dead moon or planet – SpacePhoenix Aug 25 at 16:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.