26

We know that Thor went all the way up to Nidavellir to get the Stormbreaker. But why on the earth did he not use Odin's spear? I mean, he could've scourged it from the debris of his spaceship and used it. From what I know, it’s the most powerful weapon in the whole universe.

  • 1
    Is "All powerful spear" (capital "a") the actual name of it? Or an attempt at emphasis? – Peter Mortensen Sep 10 at 17:04
55

Gungnir appears to have been left in the throne room in Asgard during Thor: Ragnarok when Ragnarok happens and Surtur destroys Asgard as I explain here. The last we see of it is when Hela disarms Thor.

Thor and Hela fighting; Hela disarms Thor

It may be obvious to some but it's also worth noting that your familiarity with a specific weapon matters a lot and even more so when switching between types of weapons. Gungnir is a staff/spear with a ranged attack whereas Stormbreaker is a big old axe which is similar to a hammer somewhat. They require vastly different fighting techniques which Thor doesn’t seem to be able to use to well.

In the duel Thor has with Hela whilst wielding Gungnir, he is easily bested. In part, this is due to him not awakening his power and Hela being super strong but he was also unfamiliar with Gungnir, being mainly a hammer user until then. He didn't use Gungnir effectively because he was unfamiliar with it.

And of course this raises another important point, if he couldn’t beat Hela with it how would he beat Thanos with the Infinity Gauntlet and the Infinity Stones in it. Of course at this point he had awakened his true power so might have been more effective with Gungnir but we don’t know for sure because we don’t see him with the spear after that.

  • 9
    Mostly evidenced by him not using a spear's natural advantage - reach. He falls back to super-close quarters, which is where he tends towards since... Mjolnir's reach isn't exactly "long". – Delioth Sep 9 at 14:41
  • 4
    Answer skirts but doesn't out and out make a rather vital point: If he couldn't use it properly to defeat Hela, what would make anyone think he'd be likely to do so successfully against a 5-stone-weilding Thanos? – T.E.D. Sep 9 at 22:50
  • 1
    @T.E.D. Good point made that more explicit. It is worth nothing though that Thor awakened his true power after losing to Hela with Gungnir so he could have been more powerful with it afterwards we just don’t see. – TheLethalCarrot Sep 10 at 6:05
  • 2
    @Delioth Heh, I'd suspect Thor's use of the spear has more to do with the producers thinking "what would look cool" than anything else. No-one in film ever uses a spear like a spear. : ) – Grimm The Opiner Sep 10 at 7:07
  • 1
    😂😂😂so true. Even the wakandans use it as blasters. Then why even make them in the shape of a spear??🤔🤔😂 – d4rk4ng31 Sep 10 at 14:25
18

Asgard and everything on it was destroyed at the end of Thor: Ragnarok, I see no reason why this spear would have survived. If there was some reason for it to be around still then you still have to consider that it would have taken quite a while to find it amidst all of the space debris, there's a good chance they would have never found it. They were racing against time, or more specifically against Thanos, to get this weapon and stop him before he had all 6 Stones. If they had taken too long collecting it Thanos could achieve his goals before they had any chance to do anything about it.

So even if it were out there it would have been too much of a risk to take any significant amount of time looking for it.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.