In the 2019 animated movie Batman: Hush, the main antagonist, Hush is revealed to be none other than

The Riddler.

However, this is a complete deviation from the comics where the character of Hush was Bruce's childhood friend Dr. Thomas Elliot.

Although the key plot points of the story in the film coincides with the 12-issue storyline Batman: Hush (by Loeb and Lee) such as:

1. The Riddler was diagnosed with terminal cancer and uses one of the Lazarus Pits to cure himself.

2. Due to his exposure to the mystical properties of the Lazarus pit, he deduces that Bruce Wayne is Batman.

The major plot change was the reveal of the person behind the mask of Hush.

Is there an explanation provided by the writers (of the movie or the comics) as to why this drastic change was introduced in the movie?


Interview with Screewriter Ernie Altbacker:

Batman Hush Uses Red Herrings To Fake Out Fans - SDCC 2019

The reason is two-fold:

  1. Time constraints of condensing a 12-part mini-series into 70 minutes
  2. Faking Out the audience to keep a familiar story fresh

The original story had a lot of red-herrings. Going with one of them as the actual new ending instead of a dead-end, allowed them to condense the story and surprise the audience.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.