9

Since it is accepted and clear that Kara Thrace was a Seraph, did this Seraph have those weird visions/etc that lead her on to the suicide mission in the viper?

What exactly pushed her to kill herself? Why did this Seraph want to kill herself?

8
  • possible duplicate of What was Starbuck? – Jack B Nimble Aug 27 '12 at 22:21
  • @JackBNimble That thread doesnt answer Q(2), which is realted to Q(1) – Spacey Aug 27 '12 at 22:34
  • I recommend you remove the first question then. – Jack B Nimble Aug 27 '12 at 22:41
  • @JackBNimble Done. – Spacey Aug 27 '12 at 22:48
  • 1
    @JackBNimble I dont know, are you saying she was? I dont know if Seraphs necessarily leave corporeal remains that rot. – Spacey Aug 27 '12 at 23:08
12

First of all, I would be hesistant to call anything about the Battlestar Galactica finale accepted, and definately not clear. Large portions of it were left ambiguous on purpose, and I'm pretty sure Starbuck's nature/role was one of those things.

However, you are correct that the most popular and best-known fan theory is that she was some sort of angel. This theory generally accepts that Kara was human up until the point that her Viper appeared to explode, though it instead jumped to old-Earth with her inside, dead.

From that point on, the theory goes, she is resurrected as an angel, though unaware of her own nature (or else a really good in-universe actress). Every action she takes from that point onward is geared towards leading the humans to Earth.

As far as why the human Kara was willing to fly into the star and explode, keep in mind that she had just finished having a vision of a head-Leoben (an avatar like the head-Six and head-Baltar) who told her to stop fearing death and follow her destiny. Also, she did not actually explode, but was somehow transported away to old-Earth. She seems to have sensed that something deeper was happening to her at the time. Therefore, she must have decided that flying into the solar storm was part of her destiny, even if it meant potentially dying.

4
  • I agree, this is why I had asked about what she was to begin with. About the post, why then I wonder, did the human-Kara want to die, or feel compelled to suicide herself though?... – Spacey Aug 27 '12 at 23:31
  • 2
    There's a world of difference difference between "want to die"/"compelled to suicide" and "she must have decided that flying into the solar storm was part of her destiny, even if it meant potentially dying." The later does not necessarily imply the former. – Bevan Aug 28 '12 at 5:46
  • 1
    @bevan in fairness, I edited my answer in response to his comment :) – KutuluMike Aug 28 '12 at 14:35
  • @Mohammad While Kara may not have "wanted" to die, she never feared death either, as shown in a flashback scene in the final episode of the series. – Unsigned May 26 '14 at 2:31
1

She said she wasn't afraid anymore to Lee right before her plane exploded. All she could think about was either death, (due to her childhood upbringing and the sheer fact that fighter pilots have to be a little friendly with the concept of death,) or her part in finding earth. The idea, the pull of her "destiny" and that it was already written for her, it wasnt suicide, it was trusting and accepting the voice that told her she would find earth, and that there was nothing to fear.

As for when she comes back, I believe that she is an Angel. Her fate and Anders had to be intertwined as love is such a strong theme in the show. Everything they ever did was for each other. In life or in death, it was her destiny to find earth, and once they finally found it, as Anders put it when she said her goodbye "Ill see you on the other side", leading me to believe that as on of the final 5 and the new, "prophet?" He has seen whats on the other side and knows that Kara will be there to meet him. He's been waiting for her for years, putting up with her complete obsession and dies for her because he loves and believes in her. She could never give him the love that he deserved back because her destiny wasn't complete. Once she heard the song and Jumped them to the real earth, Her soul became at peace. She finally has the chance to have the life she wanted, but was never allowed, to be with Anders together, on the other side.

-2

I'd like to offer an alternative but serious answer to this question.

We'll never know why Kara Thrace / this Seraph wanted to kill herself.

The writers didn't have a coherent plan other than "God / The Supernatural" was involved (you know he doesn't like that name)...

Once you have Kara standing in a field chatting to Apollo then blinked out of existence the next, you've revealed she isn't / never was human and any speculation as to why she did the things she did can only ever be speculation.

I guess I better, um, get going. - Uh, yeah. It was nice to meet you Lee Adama. - Likewise, Kara Thrace. enter image description here

-2

I disagree, well to an extent, i believe that starbuck is the goddess aurora( goddess of the dawn) i.e dawn of man. Aurora renews herself each dawn i.e in the show each dawn of man, possibly why she finds her old self on original earth.starbuck is happy to accept death to achieve her destiny, as she maybe understands in those final seconds that she will be reborn, new starbuck new ship, therefore reborn.which is obviously hinted at throughout the show. She prays to the gods, her mother knows she has a destiny and prepares her for it, the aurora figurehead given to her by the ORACLE( another reference). This figurehead being placed on the front of adamas boat which symbolises galactica and starbuck leading the way. Also aurora is usually depicted very sexually and is promiscuous which starbuck is really throughout the show. References from hotdog saying shes slept with half the fleet and being happy to cheat with apollo behind his brothers back and sams. Thats my opinion anyway.

3
  • 1
    This is just speculation... – Andres F. Mar 12 '15 at 15:52
  • Ofcourse it's speculation, it's just one opinion in the end but no more speculative than any other guess at what starbuck was. Jay – Jay Mar 17 '15 at 16:09
  • Don't take it the wrong way, but the more speculative your answer is (i.e. the closer to a personal opinion), the more likely it is to get downvoted. Some degree of speculation is ok and even unavoidable, but in this site you should strive to write answers supported by the source material, with references if possible. It's not clear cut, but your answer leans towards the "mostly speculative" end of the spectrum. – Andres F. Mar 17 '15 at 17:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.